here is the website:
link
1. he/she just said "its not" (completley agree with them)
1 1/2. (y is there a half?) the person just said that its not.
2. i dont think that many ppl can relate 2 twilight b/c we aren't that obessissive to jump off a cliff or hurt ourselves 4 r sweeties (at least i hope not), i dont feel any emotion at all and i certaintley don't want 2 b bella. Harry Potter has a story 2 and it's better. (response to "It's as if u hav a story")When I read Harry Potter, I feel as if I understand him better then bella because he goes through a lot more then bella.
2. (i think its unfair that there is another reason #2) 1st of all: the spelling is completley incorrect. 2nd of all: Harry Potter has love in it and "Da sacrifize ov life 2 save othurs isnt luv at all" is a stupid statement cause if you are sacrificing yourself to save others, isn't that "luv"? For example: Snape nearly sacrificed his life to protect Harry and it was all because of his love for Lily.
3. They just said it, Harry Potter is far superior then twilight.
4. This reason is weak, just because theres a character you like in the book does not mean that the book is better. I could say that because Bellatrix Lestrange is in the book, it is a better book.
5. if this answer isn't sarcastic, then I would say that this person just said the reason why Harry Potter is better then Twilight unknowlingly.
6. Twilight could not be true because ther are vampires inside it and they don't exist. "Harry Potter is just some teenage kids who deperatley need to grow up". I actually think that it's Bella who needs to grow up because she mostly whines about things that she can't have and she is really ungrateful. The Harry Potter characters have grown up throughout the series, even Draco. As for comparing it with Romeo and Juliet, it is nothing like it. The love between Romeo and Juliet is forbidden and in Twilight, a lot of people are welcoming it. I don;t see how it compares with Romeo and Juliet(although I don't like it.)
7. This person just said that Harry Potter is better.
8. Yeah, "it's not better"
9. Since this person did not read Harry Potter, this does not count.
10. Romance does not mean everything, family come sfirst you know. The fact that Edward and Bella are meant to be each other and and the realtionship is "perfect" is unrealistic. Ron and Hermione didn't run so perfectly which is realistic to me. The rest of the message I didn't make sense of.
11. Another Harry Potter fan.
12. They just said Harry Potter is better.
13. There are relateable wizards in Harry Potter and Harry has been clumsy before which I think was really funny. Bella is someone I can not relate to.
14. Another person who said that it's not.
15. In Harry Potter, there are werewolves. And there are more creatures in Harry Potter then in Twilight. As for "who can't luv Jacob?..." That is not a reason. Who can't love Luna anyways?
16. What do you mean by "..is the fantasy that is real?". I thought that fantasy was not real. And people in Harry Potter can do more then read minds and see the future.
17. 1st if all: Your first reason is your opinion.
Remember that. 2nd of all: Harry Potter has lots of twists and turns, like when Snape was really on the good side. We all knew that Bella was going to fall for Edward. There is romance in Harry Potter, Harry/Ginny, Hermione/Ron.
18. Harry Potter is more going in deph and emotion because there is more feeling(maybe because of the deaths)I didn't feel Bella's pain. I felt Harry's when Fred died. I felt his pain when Ginny kissed Dean, (and thats saying something cause I am a girl)
19. Harry Potter has love. Please read the books.
20. J K Rowling CHOSE to write in "the chosen one's" point of view and he is still a teenager. He is just like everyone else(you know what i mean) Bella is normal to me which is just annoying because she can't do anything. And how many people fall in love with a vampire. (My taste is better then that)
21. Again, my response is just like #4. And Wizards can do more then wave their wands.
22. Why is Bella's thoughts more realistic then Harry Potter? I'm pretty sure that Harry would think that Edward is being controlling towards Bella and Bella doesn't even know it. I couldn't understand the rest of the message.
23. I don't think that thinking long words is part of people's thoughts. And the parts when Harry Potter listed landscape in his head is when he doesn't fight evil, saavy? (I just felt like adding that in. Don't ask.)
24. I felt Harry's pain better then Bella's pain. I felt bored and confused when I read from Bella's point of view.
25. 1. It is pretty stupid to list that vampire baseball is better then quidditch as a reason.
2. Quidditch is better cause it is really original and vampire baseball is just like baseball but more extreme. And if you're not a vamp, then you can't play it.
26. "Cullens would die for each other" They didn't really die and the people fighting at Hogwarts died all for Harry and to save the world. YOu should't have included that the cullens are faster and stronger cause that means it will be easier for them to sacrifice themselves.
27. A reason that Harry Potter is better.
28. Hermione is more realistic because she is more flawed and sometimes bossy,(proving that she isn't perfect) Bella has a more confusing personality and is really ungrateful and she mostly does the exact opposite of what most people would do. Bella also did not defend herself from a rapist. And Bella is helpless and kinda stupid.
29. Reason why Harry Potter is better.
30. This is not a reason. You just said some info about the twilight werewolves.
31. They said Twilight sux!
32. So? Molly and Arther are great parents.
33. Same respnse as #30.
34. This is not a reason. And whoses side are you on?
35. J K Rowling paid attention to the facts she wrote out.
36. Britain is a real place you know? And vampires are not real.
37. Just because edward would kill harry (it's not true), does not make it better.
38. If vampires are better, it still doesn't make Twilight better then Harry Potter.
39. A reason why Harry Potter is better.
40. Another reason why Harry Potter is better.
41. This is a stupid reason and I am not goin to respond to this (mostly because I can't understand this)
42. Another Harry Potter is better reason.
43. There are more loveable characters in Harry Potter too. Ron, Fred, Hermione, Luna, etc. Twilight is not realistic because of Bella's bizarre reactions, and the fact that everyone seems to like Bella. Twilight is not well written. Stephanie Meyer should pay more attention to the important parts of the story rather then Edwards dazzling eyes. And Twilight is not interesting because of the lack of action, interesting dialouge, and commone sense. Harry Potter is not boring and completley out because every bit of Harry Potter has an important detail in it, and there is os much going on and the whole thinkg is not shoved right in front of your face.
44. Your reason is mostly your opinion. Harry Potter is more then an elected lightning bolt on his forehead. He has to defeat the dark lord and faces his fears and loses his loved ones.
45. Another Harry Potter is better reason.
46. Twilight does not have a better story line because it is not focused. In the first book, Edward has to hide Bella and kill James. It also centers around Bella meeting Edward. In the second book, it centers around Edward leaving Bella and going into four months of blank. Then she meets Jacob and his werewolf gang has to protect Bella from Victoria. In the third book, it just centers around the love triangle between Bella, Jacob and Edward and who she should choose. In Breaking Dawn, it mainly centers on Bella's baby and on how they should keep her. In Harry Potter, many things go on but J K Rowling centers the whole thing on defeating Voldemort. And the werewolf in Harry Potter is better then the werewolves in Twilight.
47. Harry Potter is more people of all ages, not just for kids. Harry Potter has some romance in it too. And Harry Potter makes you think back in the stories and it might make you smart.
48. Harry Potter has lots of love in it, more then romance. Harry Potter is more realistic; I already explained why its realistic in the other reasons. Harry Potter has great characters too; Harry, Fred, Ron, Hermione, Bellatrix, George etc. Characters that are the same are pretty boring and it means that the author did not give much description in here.
49. Harry Potter has love, the main theme is love. It also has mystery, where the horcruxes are, which side Snape is on, etc. And Harry Potter has lots of fantasy in it. Also I can imagine myself inside the story because the author described the places more well.... descriptive.
50. This isn't saying that Twilight is better then Harry Potter. It's just saying that we shouldn't compare these two.
I'll do the rest later.
*the page could be edited*
link
1. he/she just said "its not" (completley agree with them)
1 1/2. (y is there a half?) the person just said that its not.
2. i dont think that many ppl can relate 2 twilight b/c we aren't that obessissive to jump off a cliff or hurt ourselves 4 r sweeties (at least i hope not), i dont feel any emotion at all and i certaintley don't want 2 b bella. Harry Potter has a story 2 and it's better. (response to "It's as if u hav a story")When I read Harry Potter, I feel as if I understand him better then bella because he goes through a lot more then bella.
2. (i think its unfair that there is another reason #2) 1st of all: the spelling is completley incorrect. 2nd of all: Harry Potter has love in it and "Da sacrifize ov life 2 save othurs isnt luv at all" is a stupid statement cause if you are sacrificing yourself to save others, isn't that "luv"? For example: Snape nearly sacrificed his life to protect Harry and it was all because of his love for Lily.
3. They just said it, Harry Potter is far superior then twilight.
4. This reason is weak, just because theres a character you like in the book does not mean that the book is better. I could say that because Bellatrix Lestrange is in the book, it is a better book.
5. if this answer isn't sarcastic, then I would say that this person just said the reason why Harry Potter is better then Twilight unknowlingly.
6. Twilight could not be true because ther are vampires inside it and they don't exist. "Harry Potter is just some teenage kids who deperatley need to grow up". I actually think that it's Bella who needs to grow up because she mostly whines about things that she can't have and she is really ungrateful. The Harry Potter characters have grown up throughout the series, even Draco. As for comparing it with Romeo and Juliet, it is nothing like it. The love between Romeo and Juliet is forbidden and in Twilight, a lot of people are welcoming it. I don;t see how it compares with Romeo and Juliet(although I don't like it.)
7. This person just said that Harry Potter is better.
8. Yeah, "it's not better"
9. Since this person did not read Harry Potter, this does not count.
10. Romance does not mean everything, family come sfirst you know. The fact that Edward and Bella are meant to be each other and and the realtionship is "perfect" is unrealistic. Ron and Hermione didn't run so perfectly which is realistic to me. The rest of the message I didn't make sense of.
11. Another Harry Potter fan.
12. They just said Harry Potter is better.
13. There are relateable wizards in Harry Potter and Harry has been clumsy before which I think was really funny. Bella is someone I can not relate to.
14. Another person who said that it's not.
15. In Harry Potter, there are werewolves. And there are more creatures in Harry Potter then in Twilight. As for "who can't luv Jacob?..." That is not a reason. Who can't love Luna anyways?
16. What do you mean by "..is the fantasy that is real?". I thought that fantasy was not real. And people in Harry Potter can do more then read minds and see the future.
17. 1st if all: Your first reason is your opinion.
Remember that. 2nd of all: Harry Potter has lots of twists and turns, like when Snape was really on the good side. We all knew that Bella was going to fall for Edward. There is romance in Harry Potter, Harry/Ginny, Hermione/Ron.
18. Harry Potter is more going in deph and emotion because there is more feeling(maybe because of the deaths)I didn't feel Bella's pain. I felt Harry's when Fred died. I felt his pain when Ginny kissed Dean, (and thats saying something cause I am a girl)
19. Harry Potter has love. Please read the books.
20. J K Rowling CHOSE to write in "the chosen one's" point of view and he is still a teenager. He is just like everyone else(you know what i mean) Bella is normal to me which is just annoying because she can't do anything. And how many people fall in love with a vampire. (My taste is better then that)
21. Again, my response is just like #4. And Wizards can do more then wave their wands.
22. Why is Bella's thoughts more realistic then Harry Potter? I'm pretty sure that Harry would think that Edward is being controlling towards Bella and Bella doesn't even know it. I couldn't understand the rest of the message.
23. I don't think that thinking long words is part of people's thoughts. And the parts when Harry Potter listed landscape in his head is when he doesn't fight evil, saavy? (I just felt like adding that in. Don't ask.)
24. I felt Harry's pain better then Bella's pain. I felt bored and confused when I read from Bella's point of view.
25. 1. It is pretty stupid to list that vampire baseball is better then quidditch as a reason.
2. Quidditch is better cause it is really original and vampire baseball is just like baseball but more extreme. And if you're not a vamp, then you can't play it.
26. "Cullens would die for each other" They didn't really die and the people fighting at Hogwarts died all for Harry and to save the world. YOu should't have included that the cullens are faster and stronger cause that means it will be easier for them to sacrifice themselves.
27. A reason that Harry Potter is better.
28. Hermione is more realistic because she is more flawed and sometimes bossy,(proving that she isn't perfect) Bella has a more confusing personality and is really ungrateful and she mostly does the exact opposite of what most people would do. Bella also did not defend herself from a rapist. And Bella is helpless and kinda stupid.
29. Reason why Harry Potter is better.
30. This is not a reason. You just said some info about the twilight werewolves.
31. They said Twilight sux!
32. So? Molly and Arther are great parents.
33. Same respnse as #30.
34. This is not a reason. And whoses side are you on?
35. J K Rowling paid attention to the facts she wrote out.
36. Britain is a real place you know? And vampires are not real.
37. Just because edward would kill harry (it's not true), does not make it better.
38. If vampires are better, it still doesn't make Twilight better then Harry Potter.
39. A reason why Harry Potter is better.
40. Another reason why Harry Potter is better.
41. This is a stupid reason and I am not goin to respond to this (mostly because I can't understand this)
42. Another Harry Potter is better reason.
43. There are more loveable characters in Harry Potter too. Ron, Fred, Hermione, Luna, etc. Twilight is not realistic because of Bella's bizarre reactions, and the fact that everyone seems to like Bella. Twilight is not well written. Stephanie Meyer should pay more attention to the important parts of the story rather then Edwards dazzling eyes. And Twilight is not interesting because of the lack of action, interesting dialouge, and commone sense. Harry Potter is not boring and completley out because every bit of Harry Potter has an important detail in it, and there is os much going on and the whole thinkg is not shoved right in front of your face.
44. Your reason is mostly your opinion. Harry Potter is more then an elected lightning bolt on his forehead. He has to defeat the dark lord and faces his fears and loses his loved ones.
45. Another Harry Potter is better reason.
46. Twilight does not have a better story line because it is not focused. In the first book, Edward has to hide Bella and kill James. It also centers around Bella meeting Edward. In the second book, it centers around Edward leaving Bella and going into four months of blank. Then she meets Jacob and his werewolf gang has to protect Bella from Victoria. In the third book, it just centers around the love triangle between Bella, Jacob and Edward and who she should choose. In Breaking Dawn, it mainly centers on Bella's baby and on how they should keep her. In Harry Potter, many things go on but J K Rowling centers the whole thing on defeating Voldemort. And the werewolf in Harry Potter is better then the werewolves in Twilight.
47. Harry Potter is more people of all ages, not just for kids. Harry Potter has some romance in it too. And Harry Potter makes you think back in the stories and it might make you smart.
48. Harry Potter has lots of love in it, more then romance. Harry Potter is more realistic; I already explained why its realistic in the other reasons. Harry Potter has great characters too; Harry, Fred, Ron, Hermione, Bellatrix, George etc. Characters that are the same are pretty boring and it means that the author did not give much description in here.
49. Harry Potter has love, the main theme is love. It also has mystery, where the horcruxes are, which side Snape is on, etc. And Harry Potter has lots of fantasy in it. Also I can imagine myself inside the story because the author described the places more well.... descriptive.
50. This isn't saying that Twilight is better then Harry Potter. It's just saying that we shouldn't compare these two.
I'll do the rest later.
*the page could be edited*
I don't want to hear about Harry Potter or any other book right now. I'm not setting this up for a debate about which is better. I just want to know seriously and honestly why you Twilight fans enjoy reading Twilight. I want to see an actual reason that Twilight is a good book.
If you don't like Twilight, I don't want to hear you saying anything bad about it. I just want to know why people like it. Because all the debate's I've seen have no actual reasons. They have HP fans and Twihards going on about which book is better, but not why they like it.
I do actually want respectful debate though. I want to discuss the reasons you give, but nicely.
If you can't be respectful of each other's opinions then just don't comment.
And I'm not trying to hate on Twilight, but if I disagree with you I will debate with you.
I don't know if there are other debate's about this, so I'm sorry if there are, but I didn't look.
I'm just rambling now so let's get onto it!
If you don't like Twilight, I don't want to hear you saying anything bad about it. I just want to know why people like it. Because all the debate's I've seen have no actual reasons. They have HP fans and Twihards going on about which book is better, but not why they like it.
I do actually want respectful debate though. I want to discuss the reasons you give, but nicely.
If you can't be respectful of each other's opinions then just don't comment.
And I'm not trying to hate on Twilight, but if I disagree with you I will debate with you.
I don't know if there are other debate's about this, so I'm sorry if there are, but I didn't look.
I'm just rambling now so let's get onto it!
