answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

How could someone possibly (still) like Twilight?

Do explain, seriously.


Team Jo.
*
Maybe because no one has tolled them that true love isn't like in the twilight series. Many girls think that killing yourself for a man because he left you e.i. "I cant' live without you so I'm going to die" or " Life nothing without you", having an overpowering(extremele jelous) boyfriend, or being treated bad by them is romantic, and they say thats how they show their love for them. NOT! By the way if your boyfriend doesn't care about you and leaves you, MOVE ON BECAUSE LIFE GOES ON!
EYBanuelos posted over a year ago
*
I messed up on this one, what I meant was "Life is nothing without you!"
EYBanuelos posted over a year ago
 ng__ posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

oxblondiexo said:
That is a poor generalization roselaughsalot. I, for one, am not deluded enough to imagine that I could find "a man like Edward Cullen". Twilight is purely a work of fiction, and a fantasy fiction at that. Personally, that is why I like to read, and in this case, like to read Twilight, because it is simply a form of escapism.

I know that vampires and werewolves, and Edward Cullen and Jacob Black along with them, or not real and are completely fictitious. And I do not doubt many other readers know it too.

Despite this rash generalization, you did make a far point in that Twilight is not everything. Twilight is only a small part of my life, and I try to distance myself from the hysteria that surrounds the majority of Twilight fans. They can be irrational and obsessive, but that does not mean that all are like that.

I would also like to add (not in regards to roselaughsalot) that although Twilight is at times badly written, it is irrelevant to the story. Stories are, as I said before, a form of escapism. And if you - as I am sure many other people are - growing tiresome of the Twilight universe, try your best to tune it out. If this is too hard for you, if you find there is no way around it, you should be comfortable knowing you are not like that, it’s fine to not agree with people, it’s called freedom of speech. You are able to express your opinions in the correct way, on a forum or domain where you can debate with others in an appropriate way.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah, not all Twilight fans are obsessed. (This post does NOT mean I'm a Twilight fan)
PirateNinja3815 posted over a year ago
*
wow....tht required some deep thinking huh? still......i lik it and i voted u best answer!!!!!!!!
tayroxyea posted over a year ago
*
Of course there are better vampire-oriented series' out there. I agree with that. I don't understand why so many people have a connection to the story. But they do, and there's nothing anyone can do about it. In regards to the second point you made, I understand where you're coming from. Twilight to Breaking Dawn is a timeline of under two years. But I also think that the audience would have got bored and lost interest. They wouldn't have been bothered to stay loyal to the series if it wasn't as fast-paced.
oxblondiexo posted over a year ago
TEAM-EDWARDxxx said:
I like Twilight :)

I dont think that its the right way to put 'true love' and thinks its right, Most people on here just jump to conclusions saying that EVERY Twilight Fan is going to go out and find a boy friend just like Edward and fall deeply in love with him..Its not like that for some, I like Twilight because i just loved reading it, i enjoyed reading about Vampires,werewolves,humans all mixed together in one world, some may think its 'badly written' and 'how could ANY one like it' But people have their own oppionons and 'i liked reading Twilight'! if you dont like that then fine, think what you wanna think.

But im proud to say that "IM A TWILIGHT FAN"

Soo everyone get over it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I totally agree with you !!!!!! :D
AnaRoseCullen posted over a year ago
*
harry potter has wizards, witchs, cetarurs, 3 headed dogs, hipogriffs, vamps, werewolfs, owls, muggles, goblins, trolls, giants and more and it is also about love
dobbyssocks posted over a year ago
*
I'M A TWILIGHT FAN!! (I know this was posted 5 months ago and I'm commenting now)
Hjj211 posted over a year ago
Free_Spirit said:
Because Twilight awoke a longing in every girl for true love. But they need to see that Twiliight is a crap book and is badly written. But they want someone to care enough for them that they would risk they're lives for you or they would go in a depression if they parted with you. cough cough can you say lamer. Twilight is an obsession story and bad message to girls all around.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
True love isnt where some guy tells you who you should socialise with and whatnot. They accept you for who you are and dont try to change you :) I liked what you said Free-Spirit :)
Faith-Rulz posted over a year ago
*
thankyou
Free_Spirit posted over a year ago
*
If my boyfriend risked his life for me constantly I'd be pissed. I love him, I don't want him getting hurt!
swimchick posted over a year ago
roselaughsalot said:
People still like Twilight, especially girls, because they want a man like Edward Cullen, or Jacob Black. I'm NOT a Twilight fan. I simply hate it and i hope people realise that Twilight isn't everything.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I'll admit that I have read these books, and if there are at least some girls out there who at least like Jacob better than Edward, well that's a start. Edward is crazy and controlling, at least Jacob doesn't teach girls that obsession=love.
swimchick posted over a year ago
*
I'm not a Twi-fan, just to clarify.
swimchick posted over a year ago
*
Nahh Jacob just encourages Cheating
TEAM-EDWARDxxx posted over a year ago
nessienjake said:
well i hate writing long answers but you give me no choice.
well before answering why do you like harrypotter?
its for the same reason some people love twilight.

and im sorry for being mean now but i really dont feel like writing why i like twilight and anyway would it change your life if people told you why they like/hate it???
makes sense...
I could to say how could someone possibly still like harrypotter but i dont because it's not my business and im tired over the same question everytime!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
you don't want to write about why you like twilight, but you're totally fine with writing about not wanting to write? That makes PERFECT sense....
nati30 posted over a year ago
*
huh? i dont get it! wats ur point?
tayroxyea posted over a year ago
*
lol know that i re-read what i wrote Im confused xD
nessienjake posted over a year ago
jannette_camou said:
I must say I am or now I think I could say WAS a Twilight fan., I really like the books at first I couldnt put them Down But As I read the books again I Was like WTF this book is so un real)Im not saying Twilight is a bad book and that no one should read it.But It is badly writen I dont think girls realize because they are all caught up in the Forbiden love ,Or True love and the Edward Cullen just give them time they will all snap out of it soon.. :\ I hope I Dont think the world can stand another sec with all these Twilight fan girls hahaha Some are insane hmmm maybe the cure is I better book HP anyone.? lmao
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I stand by what I said in my prior comment that the writing doesn't matter as much as the story, BUT I was re-reading one of my favourite chapters and I was lik , "This is so badly written!" So I get where you're coming from.
oxblondiexo posted over a year ago
mimifaith said:
my honest answer to this question is that I DON'T KNOW!!!
harry potter is ten million times better than twilight and it was ok for people to like twilight when it first came out, but now? seriously?
select as best answer
my honest answer to this question is that I DON'T KNOW!!!
harry potter is ten million times better than twilight and it was ok for people to like twilight when it first came out, but now? seriously?
posted over a year ago 
*
I have no clue how to post pics on tinypic but --- link
ng__ posted over a year ago
*
I mean on *fanpop
ng__ posted over a year ago
*
i lik ur pic! and good answer 2
tayroxyea posted over a year ago
Lackson4ever85 said:
well i think twilight and New moon its really GOOD AND AMAZING. But i love both,and i think its always will be someone some like Twilight more or Harry potter more,but its NOT importen, all have diffrent taste,i love both and cant choose between hp and twi:D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
I know the one reason why people like Twilight, and EVERY Twilight fan will deny this, but it is the one and only truth.

They like Twilight because Edward is hot. They wish a super hot boy would stalk them too.

The story? Doesn't matter. Edward's personality? Doesn't matter. As long as he is pretty, that's all that counts. Put it this way: if SMeyer had made Edward ugly (I know she never would, that's not the point). How many people would still like Twilight? Hmm... lets see... um... zero?

They also want a boy to obsess over them, which is exactly what Edward does. It's "true love" if they are ridiculously obsessed with each other, and that's the way it goes. At least, that's the way it goes in a Twilight Fan's mind. Harry Potter fans, on the other hand, know what love really is.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
swimchick posted over a year ago
*
Sorry, just had to put that before my actual comment. I'm not a Twi-fan (as I mention in my comment below), but I have to say that even though I love HP and love the romances in the books, I think that they are also a little hokey. The purest love I see in the series is in book 7, Snape's love for Lily. That is my favorite chapter and I have read it again and again with the same hunger that these crazy Twilight fans have for EC.
swimchick posted over a year ago
*
I think your answer is sooo wrong..Im a Twilight Fan :) and i dont like it becasue "Edward is hot" there are many many reasons why i like it, instead of saying that. AND i would still like the book if he was "ugly" whats wrong with ugly people huh?, Do you see an ugly person and automatically not like them or something? shallow much. And "They also want a boy to obsess over them," This i would have to say is the most ridiculous thing i have ever heard. i dont wont a boy to "obsess" over me, just beacuse a book charcter does..Books/ characters in them dont control my life, i make my own decisions, i dont follow from things in a book.
TEAM-EDWARDxxx posted over a year ago
xneville_rocksx said:
I have been sitting here at my computer for like 10 minutes and i cannot think of any reason people still like Twilight. Lets all just say Harry Potter rocks and let that be the end of this.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah!!me too!
tweely posted over a year ago
*
Me too...
_DarkPhoenix_ posted over a year ago
swimchick said:
Okay so here's my Twilight experience:

I have two sisters and I am the oldest. My middle sister had read them all and loved them. My youngest sister didn't get it after reading the first three. I read the first one with both of them breathing down my neck wondering how I'd take it. It's a super quick read and I didn't really take it seriously. My sis was disappointed, but encouraged me to read the others, so I did.

I have to say that the last three books are not necessary. The first one was more than enough for me. They're addicting and ridiculous while you're reading them. It's like a car wreck. But once you come out of the four-book coma, you realize that they're really just, eh. Fluff, bad writing, completely silly. Even while reading, you have 100 WTF moments per book.
Harry Potter is an exciting story that I can read again and again. I don't think I could ever stomach Twilight a second time. Why the hell are we comparing these two completely different things?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
The book I couldn't seem to be able to read no matter how hard I tried was Breaking Dawn. Seriously it was the most silly book I have ever read. All of them were bad but BD was the true car wreck...
_DarkPhoenix_ posted over a year ago
next question »