answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

Which series had the better last book AND WHY??

I know i added this as a pick but you need to write why you think its better.
*
i think twilight as it had so much going on and so much ontent to constantly keep you interested and reading on where as i felt harry potter dragged on a bit
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
*
Only dragged because Harry Potter involves thinking Meyer's doesn't
annoy_anonymous posted over a year ago
*
Breaking dawn sounds more like Fanfiction...
nessienjake posted over a year ago
 lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight  best answer

annoy_anonymous said:
Harry Potter and the reason why I think it is, is because it is gripping right from the start. First just getting Harry to the burrow causes the deaths of many good wizards (Meyer won't kill any of the good guys to wishy washy) and soon after Harry, Hermione and Ron are on the run from Death eater. None Pure Blood wizards are required to get papers (similar to the Jewish in WWII) leaving them to find the horcruxes only to find out that they actually found one in book 5 which many people over look (one thing that proves JK Rowling actually THINKS about the books to come) They hunt for Horcruxes in many different locations meeting Wizards and magical creatures in hiding (simlar to the Jewish in WWII) You loose many characters which you grow attached to as the series progresses. Ron abandons Harry's mission and comes back showing Friendship/love helps conquer evil. Have a heartbreaking realization that not everyone leaves war unscathed as Harry's godson has Harry fate of never knowing his parents. You have Harry realize he must sacrifice himself not for his love but for the sake of all the innocent. Such a huge task to have at 17 years old. Much more in depth then Meyer's characters/plot. Not only that but Harry risks his skin to save his enemy not once but 3 times. Not to mention Snapes character development absolutely amazing.

Breaking Dawn just wasn't that good. None of Meyer's book were good. They were boring full of filler. Don't really show any value whatsoever. What is consider "romantic" by Meyer is simply abusive. Also I thought vampires couldn't reproduce? Meyer is the definition of over hyped and will fade. A sparkly piece of shit may be sparkly but it is still shit.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
actaully SM did put things in the beginning books, important to the 4th book they are just SUBTLE so you realy havte to think about it...its not brought up in the last book so its up to you to noice it...
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
*
@itachifan1 : haha wizards are scary?? wouldn't you be afraid of some sparkling creepy dude stalking you and watch you sleep? and J.K will never be forgotten and what's up with all of the STFU? i think you said it like hundred of times o.O and ooh i think you forgot to take the caps lock off! and no sparkling vampires are not cool ;>)
andrealovesshia posted over a year ago
*
A sparkly piece of shit may be sparkly but it is still shit= love it!
HaleyDewit posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

November99 said:
Harry Potter. Why? Because it had plenty of action, death, and an actual battle.

Breaking Dawn I didn't read, but my friend did fill me in on it, and that book just creeps me out. No need to go into detail.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Did it creep you out because one of the main characters you're supposed to like turns out to be a pedophile?
duckey94 posted over a year ago
*
Partly, yes. But that wasn't even half of it.
November99 posted over a year ago
*
LOLLL hahahah! Jacob IS a pedophile!
TeamPotter1960 posted over a year ago
ybet_cullen18 said:
breaking dawn, because it has a romantic ending. And i like it when Aro allowed Nessie to live,.. and stephenie meyer is better than jk rowling!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I beg to differ, Meyer isn't a very good author at all. Her grammar, lack of consistancy and inability to have any character development makes her a terrible author when compared to JK Rowling. Meyer will be forgotten about in 10 years where as Rowling will live on forever, Her books are the makings of a classic.
annoy_anonymous posted over a year ago
*
i agree with annoy_anonymous
1-2vampire posted over a year ago
*
no offence TEAM-EDWARDxxx, but how could you misspell Bookaholics if it's just above where you're writing?
FredWRules posted over a year ago
zhanar said:
Harry Potter's last book was so mush better, it was emotional and had a lot of action in it, I was almost crying when Bellatrix started tourchring Hermione and Ron lost it there, it shows that he would die for her and do anything, and the book was real, it had death and tears and some minor cursing =)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
edwad would die for bella too, i felt BD was more emotional, you could feel the emotions more than in HP
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
*
But edward is abusive emotionally... Ron isn't. Edward controls where Belle goes, isolates her from her friends, tells her what to do and when to do it and talks down to her. And his excuse "To Protect" her. If you boyfriend was doing all that to "protect" you I would hope you didn't think it was romantic but that it was abusive and got help.
annoy_anonymous posted over a year ago
*
Izzy, what battle. You need to pay attention when you read, there wasn't one.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
illo said:
I have been a humongous fan of both the books until i read their last instalments & honestly the last books ruined everthing for the series.
But if i have to chose one than i guess Deathly hallows was less damaging than breaking dawn.The later really was a disaster i.e in my opinion.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
1-2vampire said:
Harry Potter. Cos OMG my mind boggles at how Rowling has stitched it all together! How can she do that???
It all comes together like the puzzle pieces falling into place.
OMG! HP ROXXX! xxx
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i agree that harry potter is geinus ..i just prefered the twilight story
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
*
I know Dude! Rowlings fricking AMAZING!!!
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
*
i agree that HP is genius, JK waas very clever with her writing and how she sewn everything together however i prefered reading twilight...
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
Bookaholics said:
To be fair, I would actually have to say Breaking Dawn. Now I'm obviously biased for Harry Potter, as I think it's a better series, but I'm not comparing the two books to each other, but to the rest of the series. Breaking Dawn was about the same as the other Twilight books,it was actually somewhat better written, and while I enjoyed DH a lot, I thought the other Harry Potter books were better. I do think DH was brilliantly plotted, but the beginning WAS draggy.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree the it was slightly draggy (is that a word??) but all in all, a spectacular book!
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
itachifan1 said:
#1 edward and bella have a baby

#2 they get married

#3 it tells all abot renesmee growing up

#4 it tell about the voltiri going after her
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
such strong reasons. I suppose I could use the 1st three points and say they were summed up in the Harry Potter epilogue. But I prefer to pretend that piece of crap never exsisted. I hated the epilogue but not nearly as much as I hated Twilight
annoy_anonymous posted over a year ago
*
^^ Just let them have their oppion.. please
TEAM-EDWARDxxx posted over a year ago
*
She's (?) just giving her opinion too. Nomatter how many times she gives it, Twilight fans gives theirs just as much.
meelottie posted over a year ago
*
Um, sorry but isn't that just summing up the book? Please don't bite my head off. I APOLOGISE IF I'VE OFFENDED ANYONE! There, I'm safe. :)
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
aurora30 said:
Ok whoa! I LOVE Harry Potter. Shit. Harry Potter and Jk Rowling are the reasons why I even pick up other books. The whole HP series is over-whelming. I mean I never got tired of reading them. I would just finish one and move on to the next without ever getting bored. JK even made them last 7! and not jus 7 short stories like the Marked series of Vampire Diaries.((Oh dnt get me wrong I Love both series)) But 7! 400 or more pages average. AT Least! But Meyers took the vampire style to a whole new genre. She on another level whn it comes to the Cullens. And I love her books for the new perspective. SO many series since have taken wat she has done and fabricated it to the other series we all kno and love. ((Mentioned them earlier and then some...etc)) SO while I kno Jk Rowling is the better author. And I owe my love of books to HP I do appreciate Twilight series as I do any other.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
my thoughts exactly :)
lauracullen66 posted over a year ago
duckey94 said:
Harry Potter. 1: The entire plot of the story did not completely contradict statements previously made by the author. 2: The plot made sense. AND it completed the main plot of the entire series. Twilight couldn't do this because there was no plot for the entire series. 3: The last scene at the end of Twilight was the most anti-climatic thing i've ever read. Meyer was just trying to push a ridiculous, unbelievable, uninteresting happy ending. J.K. actually had an epic battle, deaths, injuries, tears, SUSPENSE. I know we all hated that those characters had to die, but it made for good literature. Breaking Dawn did not. 4: There were no pedophiles that I can immediately recall in Deathly Hallows. NUFF SAID.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
-Sniff- Lupin DIED! NOOOOO!
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
*
-Sniff- Sev DIED! NOOOOO! (I wasn't aiming to be insulting or anything, I meerly wanted to express my grief in the same way.)
LilysLittleTwin posted over a year ago
*
Not Fred! *sobweepcry*
venvargie posted over a year ago
Free_Spirit said:
HARRY POTTER. Twilight but each book is basically the same plot, Bella puts everyone in danger and then they all fix it and live happily ever after. HArry Potter is much more interesting. It is realistic, with the death, the suspense. It shows that life isn't always going to turn out happy. Also it shows the development of all the characters, and some of them change, in Twilight everyone is the same. I still love the Twilight series but i think it can sometimes give a bad message, not intentionally though. Like in breaking Dawn how Bella is ready to kill herself for a child, that can be a good and bad message.
All in all both great series, but Harry Potter is probably better.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ravenclaweagle said:
Harry, of course! Hermione and Ginny aren't teen mothers, Harry doesn't "talk his problems out" with Voldemort (because how lame is that?), and it keeps you wondering and your heart racing until the last page.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Can you imagine if Harry 'talked' out his problems with Volde? Another reason HP kicks butt. Even the bad guys are badder.
Kylie90210 posted over a year ago
*
AHHH! TALKING! HARRY, VOLDY, TALKING, AHHHHH!
LilysLittleTwin posted over a year ago
*
Yeah, what's with Aro and Edward holding hands in the middle of a supposedly vampire war.
Bellatrixxx posted over a year ago
Volturrimort said:
Deathly Hallows, of course! It's a masterpiece, no doubt. After reading DH i can't help but read from Book 1 all over again. Everything makes sense. JKR raised my standards to the roof!
As for Breaking Dawn, i cursed SM for wasting my freaking time!


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
HaleyDewit said:
Harry Potter!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
greekgoddess525 said:
Harry Potter had the Better last book because j.k. Rowling is a better writer than Stephanie Meyer because she has had more experience because Harry potter has 7 books. Breaking Dawn was good but The Deathly Hallows was really good
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
helenacrazy said:
deathly hallows 4 ever
select as best answer
deathly hallows 4 ever
posted over a year ago 
*
Nice Picture!
Harrypotter148 posted over a year ago
KateKicksAss said:
I think this is kind of an unfair question to ask. Obviously, people are going to go for the book in whichever series they're a fan of.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
avrilsmylife said:
Both last books were my fave in both series but in my opinion breaking dawn because it's more what I'm into but I also love the last Harry potter
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »