Who is better dumbledore or carlisle????????

Dumbledore. His random words/quotes of wisdom can be used in every day life. My favorite and probably my favorite quote ever is;
"Happiness can be found even in the darkest of times, if one only remembers to turn on the light" ~ Albus Dumbledore Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Personally I like Dumbledore better, I never really found Carlisle to be that great even when I was a Twilight fan.

I think Carlisle is amazing, I admire him most of probably any character I've ever read.
I admire the strength he had no never kill a single person for their blood.
I admire his will to never want to kill him enemies.
I admire his will to never kill at all (besides animals)
I admire his strength to finally accept what he is and use his new found powers to do good for humanity.
I admire his compassion for other people.

Dumbledore... I like him sometimes. There were too many instances where I didn't like all the amazingly profound advice he constantly dished out. I just didn't agree with a lot of it.

Isn't there a pick asking this question floating around somewhere? I think there is.

I never really cared for Dumbledore. He's actually pretty high on my "least favorite characters" list. But Carlisle was always a favorite of mine.

Dumbledore is better...he is the greatest wizard of all time and was the owner of the elder wand. He is wise and caring and just more interesting to watch and read about.

well i try to answer,

carlisle: so so character to me. he doesn't pick my interest but at the same time doesn't have any quality that make me hate him. rather...well he just there and always supporting. that's all i see. and maybe just a little persuasive/diplomatic expert?

Dumbledore: there are time i wish harry would just shut up and trust him. and there are time i feel he is more manipulative than salazar himself. but most of the time i wish he will be alright, and happy even if it just for a little while.

so yes i gotta choose Dumbledore.

Im not even sure what your talking about... (next time be more specific, will ya?) But DUMBLEDORE... all the way!

to be honest, i dun even know why this is a question. the answer is obvious.. its dumbledore..

Dumbledore, by far.

Carlise is just sick

He turned a suicide victim who will be in this state of mind forever.

He turned a rape victim because she was beautiful while thinking she would be a good girlfriend for Edward.

While he says that he values human life yet he helps the vampires in Breaking Dawn to kill people

I'm going to have to go with Dumbledore

Carlisle: while I don't hate him he just does not hold my intrest. it seems like he does not play that big of a role for me to really become intrested in him as a character. while I do find his past a bit intresting I just don't find myself ever curious about him.he was a pretty straight forward character from the beginning I could tell he was the kind and caring father figure so there was no mystery to him.

Dumbledore: he is suppose to be this kind of representation of the light side the good side he is pretty much this powerful light wizard everyone looks up to . but what I love is that at times I found myself doubting that he was fighting for the side of good because he seemed a bit manipulative. it really suprised me when I learned dumbledores dark past. but his character kind of shows that no matter how good a person seems that there is a bit of darkness in them. that there is no such thing as a whole good person we all have to have a dark side in us.

both are equally incredible characters in my book :)

Dumbledore. Hands down.