What can anyone possibly have to say about Twilight?

You mean like topics of in depth discussion?
There are plenty.

Here are a few I've stolen from other websites:

Bella lies and sneaks to be with Edward. Does this dishonest behavior detract from her attractiveness as a character? Defend your viewpoint.

How does Twilight define good and evil?

Should Edward turn Bella into a vampire? Explain why or why not.

Does Bella more strongly represent free agency or events being dictated by destiny?

What does Carlisle signify in the novel?

Does Twilight overall seem to emphasize fate or free agency?

How can Bella be said to be, like Edward, more mature than her contemporaries?

Explain how Rosalie can be seen as Bella’s foil.

How is Bella’s love for Edward an example of true faith?

Is honesty or sacrifice the greater virtue in Twilight?

Why is Bella’s hatred of cold and rainy weather so significant?

How would Bella's life be different without Edward? Would she have found happiness elsewhere? Would this happiness be to the same caliber?

How would you react if you were in Bella's shoes? In Edward's?

How many of the antagonists are actually true villains?

Imagine if this novel had the same themes and plot, but did not involve vampires. Would anything be lost as a result? Would anything be gained?

What if the main roles were reversed? That is, what if Bella was a vampire and Edward a human? How would this change the story? What would essentially remain the same?

Did you see that Jacob would have some sort of involvement as a main character in the future?

What's the significance of the scriptural epigraph (Genesis 2:17) and the cover photo?

Meyer says that the concept of "choice" is an important one to her. How does the book illustrate that concept?

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism

What about Edward as a role model for young men?


Some of these I tweaked a bit to make more interesting.

its a book and a movie

To respond to your last sentence at first, I must disappoint you. This is not a challenge, it is starting to get boring. People asking the same thing again and again, and, of course, me, responding to every question like this on the same way. It is getting boring.

But, to answer your question, let's start easy.
As you can see, I named myself TrueTwi_Hard. Not because I am true fan of Twilight, as many of you seem to think, but because I am a fan of the true Twilight.
Every book you will ever read has a hidden message in it. Twilight says many things, but the top one is to love, nomather what happens.
Then, to show that I have really good reasons to love Twilight for what it is, I would like to show you my article. I cannot copy, it is too long, so if you would be so kind to read it, I would be grateful.

link

really getting tired of telling people the same thing over and over again...

- TrueTwi_Hard

It will never come close to being as good as Harry Potter.

That's your OPINION.

There's really plenty to discuss about it, and about anything out there, even if it's just haters like you talking about how much they DISlike something.

If you really want to know the depth of Twilight go to the fanclub "critical analysis of twilight" and you will find out it!

Don't even get me started. Twilight's offensive to women, stupid, and what kind of vampires sparkle? Last time I checked, vampires died in sunlight, not turned into a frickin glitter pixie! Alright, I should stop before I hurt someone physically. But, oh my gods, just so stupid. Shirtless boys and woodland fairies. Ickkk. >: (