Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question
Has anyone noticed that if Bella had married Jacob, she'd be "Bella Black"?
This can NOT be a coincidence!
Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers
 |
KathyHalliwell said:
Oh, good god, really? That's terrible. (And now I was being sarcastic.) Come on, so what? Bella wouldn't have married Jacob anyway, everyone knew that. It's not a big deal.
And why exactly can't it be a coincidence? What, you think she did it on purpose? I don't think so. Truth be told, Meyer probably didn't even notice it. I doubt she ever considered Bella ending up with Jacob. And anyway, I don't even think she knows Bellatrix's real name was Black. She's known as Lestrange. Who guarantees Meyer read HP? Maybe she didn't. Maybe she only saw the movie, and I don't think she would remember Bellatrix being a Black originally if she only saw the movies. So yes, I can totally see it as a coincidence. It probably is, by the way. Black is a common surname. Not everything revolves around HP.
|
|
 |
volleyblue13 said:
I noticed that! Copying much????????? Cuz that's pretty sad. Come up with your own names!
BTW, this is the REAL Bella!
|
|
 |
abitofaLunaTic said:
And the original Bella Black would have to Avada Kedavra her for besmirching the name!
Yes, it could be a coincidence, but I think it's one too many.
Big hairy dog creature with the last name Black? *cough*Sirius rip-off*cough*
And Clearwater too! Although I'm not sure she read HP closely enough to register that there was a Clearwater in it.
|
|
 |
VampiresRevenge said:
Haha, that's pretty funny. I don't think that it's copied, though. I mean, it's not like it's an uncommon last name, like Lovegood or Weasley.
|
|
 |
ToyletGnome said:
Oh.
My.
Godric.
Maybe Bellatrix saw this coming and that's why she decided to marry Rodolphus.
|
|
 |
Persephone713 said:
yeah, didnt have to look to far for names did Stephy? Plagerisim(spelling?) is a *beep*
|
|
 |
kwlski4ever said:
That's stupid.
Why can't she choose her own names instead of copying ? Wtf. Ok , Bella - I can understand that. Bella is pretty common name. Black-okay. But those two combined together are just COPYING. At least she didn't marry Jacob , so copying isn't that obvious at first. OK , mayb Smeyer DIDN'T read HP at all , so she 'made up' those herself. Okay. But CLEARWATER ?!?!? . .And then Twihards say that we are jealous . .
|
|
 |
ravenclawgirl5 said:
YES! I know! I totally noticed that before. Goodness gracious, Stephenie Meyer.
|
|
 |
zanhar1 said:
that sounds a bit like Bellatrix Black... how dare Bella Swan almost steal my Bellatrix's name?!
just shows how unorignal twilight is.
Bellatrix is angry too
|
|
 |
TeamSiriusBlack said:
Yes, but we love our own Bella and she's totally awesome in her own special way :)
|
|
 |
potterandtdi said:
F*ck Meyer and if they had a son, they named it Sirius. O_O I would murder Meyer in her sleep.
|
|
 |
qtpievy said:
i think it's kinda funny how everybody is so quick to think that she was copying the name....i mean they r two separate names that were not even put together in the books...it's just if she would have married him, so it's not really copying. I'm sure stephanie didnt even think about copying it!!!
|
|
 |
moolah said:
I didn't know that but that's so cool!Technically it would be IsaBella Black.
I like Isabella Cullen better,though.
But thank you for pointing that out!
|
|
