answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

How many of you Twilight fans have actually read Harry Potter?

I keep looking over your arguments, and they make no sense to me. "Oh, I've never read Harry Potter, but Edward is hot (Lies, by the way) so.... Twilight is better". So, I wanna know, how many of you have read the entire series?
 LilRavenclaw95 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

VampiresRevenge said:
I have. I actually read HP when I was around 8, and only read Twilight a year ago. I am a bigger fan of HP than I am Twilight.

Why would anyone be on this spot if they haven't read both series? It's a spot to compare, and if someone hasn't read the other side, then they can't compare it to anything.

I'm pretty sure there are HP fans or Antis on this spot, too, who haven't read Twilight, or have only read the first book. So, everyone on this spot has to have read both.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Thank you! I've read all four Twilight books (twice, don't ask me why), and all seven Harry Potter books about a million times. It's kind of sad that people just ramble on that Twilight is BETTER, when you have nothing to compare it to. :)
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
*
I agree. I mean, Harry Potter is EPIC WITH A SIDE OF WIN. twilight is epic with a side of fail. I have read all of the books in twilight by the way. My poor IQ... ;____;
venvargie posted over a year ago
*
I read both! My godfather introduced me to HP and I read it when I was six right up until I was twelve! Twilight took me about a week...
DJ_Squeaky posted over a year ago
BellatrixCissy said:
i acutally did before my mom let me read twilight i didn't have anything to read and we knew about HP before Twilight so i have
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
italiangirl976 said:
I admit that I have not read them. But I love the movies. And yes I know the books are better. Its always like that. Even though I have not read Harry Potter doesn't mean I can't defend Twilight. I will never bash harry potter or pretend I know things about it (other then the things from the movies, but I heard they left out a lot). I can still defend the things I like. And I still respect everyone else opinion. No matter which one they like.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I never said you couldn't defend Twilight, I'm saying that a lot of fans judge without reading. And I respect your opinion, too.
LilRavenclaw95 posted over a year ago
*
Oh I know. I've just seen other people say things about Twilight fans not reading harry potter. And Harry potter fans not reading Twiligh too. You really don't need to read the other to defend what you like. As longs as you don't bash it.
italiangirl976 posted over a year ago
*
For sure! I've read both, and I think that makes it a lot easier to make an informed decision!
LilRavenclaw95 posted over a year ago
*
Yea it helps but its not necessary
italiangirl976 posted over a year ago
LifesGoodx3 said:
I'm a Twilight fan and I'm currently reading the HP series (I'm on GoF)... I actually like HP better so far.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Go you! :)
LilRavenclaw95 posted over a year ago
*
the last three were the saddest of all :'( . but seriously was there any point in killing.. H****g
1-2vampire posted over a year ago
*
yeah i know. poor h*****g :(
magic18 posted over a year ago
pinkfluby114558 said:
i no lots! and i started them, but i only got to book like 3
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Well, that's fine as long as you stick to points from those three books,
abitofaLunaTic posted over a year ago
dakky said:
i've read EVERY SINGLE HP BOOK!! LOL..my friends think im really dorky
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
it's ok my friends KNOW i am really dorky lol
hpfreak14 posted over a year ago
topazEYEs91 said:
i've read all the hp books i love them, and i love all the movies(cant wait for deathly hallows to come out)!!!! i like both the hp series ant the twilight series...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lmt96 said:
i have acctually read them and they were pretty good verging on amazing
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »