Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

This has probably been asked already but I'm gonna ask it again

Does it seem like, the Twilight series, in everybody's opinion, seems to be more about the movies more than the books? And same goes for Harry Potter, to the people who haven't read the books yet or anything, they might've just watched the movies and based their opinions on that, which, to me, doesn't seem fair. For both series, you can't base your opinions on something that isn't accurate in the first place! The books came first, and they 're always better. It just seems, to me, that most opinions are coming from the movie versions. What do you guys think, Twi-hards and Potheads?
 boolander25 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

MadamOcta13 said:
I think that some people do base their opinions on movies, not books, but I think most of the Potheads and Twihards are on this spot because we love the original-the book.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Because, you know that other batle we're currently in right know with 2010cathy, i heard a remark, or rathjer read a remark, saying that a user liked the movies better than the books, but I thought that this was a spot for the books
boolander25 posted over a year ago
*
sry for misspells
boolander25 posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
Where's that at? I enjoy arguing with her. :D I'll join your cause, volleyblue13!
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
volleyblue13 said:
I'm not just saying this because I'm a Pothead, but I honestly think that most of Twilight's popularity is because of the movies. THAT'S when it really started getting popular. I hate it when people claim that they are "obsessed with twilight" and they've only seen the movie a couple times and really don't know any basic facts about it. I find that really pathetic.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Being completely streight-forward, a LOT of Twilight fans that I know have only seen the movies, and pretend they know everything about it
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
same here, I was just wondering if anyone thought the same
boolander25 posted over a year ago
*
same here
FranKoRocksNite posted over a year ago
TeamSiriusBlack said:
I think people only like Twilight because of the movie. Twilight the book came out in 2005 but almost no one read it. The movie came out last year and all of a sudden people are in love with it? No. They're in 'love' with how hot the cast is.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yea, but no one read it.
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
Wait... it came out that early?
potterandtdi posted over a year ago
*
It came out that early, but HP came out earlier.
AprilCandy42 posted over a year ago
*
yeah i agree and personaly i dont see whats so 'hot' about the cast
FranKoRocksNite posted over a year ago
potterandtdi said:
Yeah... I only see some comments like,"Harry is HAWT!" Yet I see a lot of comments like,"Edward is a HAWT vampire!" I think Twi-Hards base their opinion on the movie, not the book.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I mean, you can't really call a book character hot (don't get me wrong, I've had book crushes before, but not because of their appearence)
boolander25 posted over a year ago
*
excatly
potterandtdi posted over a year ago
AprilCandy42 said:
Yes. Actually, I never knew Twilight until the movie came out. Usually, HP fans base their opinions on the movies, and sometimes, the book. Twilight fans say Edward's hot because Robert Pattinson is "hot", or at least I think they do. But Twilight fans base their opinions on the books too (like saying Twilight is "love")
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Ah, that's true
boolander25 posted over a year ago
italiangirl976 said:
I think your right. I am a Twilight fan. A lot of people talk more about the movies then the books and a lot of people judge the books based on the movies. Personally I think the movies sucked compared to the books. So I don't think its fair to judge them based on the movies. As for Harry potter, I have never read the books. I just love the movies. I know that the books are probably better then the movies but I've just never read them.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah when you base your facts on movies that aren't really even that accurate (you even said the TWilight movies sucked; same did the HP movies) it just screws up your perception on everything.
boolander25 posted over a year ago
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!