answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

how come people like hp more than gorgeous edward cullen

*
Wait, is this a serious question? O.o
silverandgreen7 posted over a year ago
*
silverandgreen7: I thought it was a joke too... at first
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
I've been thinking. Maybe the reason why Edward's skin is all sparkly is because he has a really bad case of psoriasis.
Pensieve_Seeker posted over a year ago
 coolbek posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight  best answer

boolander25 said:
Because not everyone is a shallow reader.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
^^ now THAT was a burn
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
^Rofl, it was XD!\
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
Yes it was. You just said EVERYTHING.
i-am-mariella posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

volleyblue13 said:
*gawks*... seriously? SERIOUSLY??? Did you REALLY just ask that question?!?!?! Ok, you asked for it...

FIRST OF ALL: Harry is HOTTER that freaking Edward Sparkle Boy. Also, Harry has a personality and isn't bipolar. He treats Ginny with respect and truly cares about her, he doesn't end up marrying her and having kids because she "smells good". Harry actually CARES about his friends, too. He is very brave and a great leader, unlike Eddykins. Furthermore, Ginny and Harry actually LIKE each other and are a great couple. They were friends since they met, and they slowly grew into a relationship. And their love is actually LOVE, not lust being called love. Harry actually has brains, aswell. He may not be really "book smart", but he has very good insticts and can be very smart at times. Eddy? No.

Harry also knows how to pick his friends, and he STICKS BY THEM. He is so loyal, and will always defend his friends. He didn't care what other people thought when he sat with Luna and Neville on the train, because he is very kind and doesn't let popularity influence him. He is a true friend through and through. Edward and Bella abandon their friends and are selfish throughout the series. They only care about themselves and they don't seem to care about anyone, even friends who loved them, whatsoever. Need I say more?

Harry is a WIZARD, which shows true awesomeness. Edward is a SPARKLY VAMPIRE..... gay much????? REAL vampires die in the sun, not sparkle!
Harry plays Quidditch. Quidditch VS Baseball? Do I even have to tell you who wins there??? Didn't think so. In addition, Harry goes to HOGWARTS, a MAGICAL school. Edward goes to a regular high school. WOOHOO!

Finally, Harry actually has a life and goes on multiple adventures. What does Eddy boy do all his life? Stalk his girlfriend. Now THAT is not sad at ALL (sarcasm).
Overall, Harry Potter's entire personality, life, and looks are FAR better than Edward "Sparkly Fairy" Cullen.
select as best answer
*gawks*... seriously? SERIOUSLY??? Did you REALLY just ask that question?!?!?! Ok, you asked for it...

FIRST OF ALL: Harry is HOTTER that freaking Edward Sparkle Boy. Also, Harry has a personality and isn't bipolar. He treats Ginny with respect and truly cares about her, he doesn't end up marrying her and having kids because she "smells good". Harry actually CARES about his friends, too. He is very brave and a great leader, unlike Eddykins. Furthermore, Ginny and Harry actually LIKE each other and are a great couple. They were friends since they met, and they slowly grew into a relationship. And their love is actually LOVE, not lust being called love. Harry actually has brains, aswell. He may not be really "book smart", but he has very good insticts and can be very smart at times. Eddy? No.

Harry also knows how to pick his friends, and he STICKS BY THEM. He is so loyal, and will always defend his friends. He didn't care what other people thought when he sat with Luna and Neville on the train, because he is very kind and doesn't let popularity influence him. He is a true friend through and through. Edward and Bella abandon their friends and are selfish throughout the series. They only care about themselves and they don't seem to care about anyone, even friends who loved them, whatsoever. Need I say more?

Harry is a WIZARD, which shows true awesomeness. Edward is a SPARKLY VAMPIRE..... gay much????? REAL vampires die in the sun, not sparkle!
Harry plays Quidditch. Quidditch VS Baseball? Do I even have to tell you who wins there??? Didn't think so. In addition, Harry goes to HOGWARTS, a MAGICAL school. Edward goes to a regular high school. WOOHOO!

Finally, Harry actually has a life and goes on multiple adventures. What does Eddy boy do all his life? Stalk his girlfriend. Now THAT is not sad at ALL (sarcasm).
Overall, Harry Potter's entire personality, life, and looks are FAR better than Edward "Sparkly Fairy" Cullen.
posted over a year ago 
*
agreed!!!! =D
eli218 posted over a year ago
*
lmt96: Wow, I'm SOO offended by you're very intelligent words! *sarcasm* I LOVE how you just said "so there" like you proved me wrong or something... WOW.
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
Daniel Radcliffe looks brilliant with green eyes... but his eyes can't tolerate contacts so they couldn't do it - Damn. anyways yeah your answer OWNS.
Wotcher_Harry posted over a year ago
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
Because I find good personality to be far more meaningful, beautiful and desirable than good looks.
select as best answer
Because I find good personality to be far more meaningful, beautiful and desirable than good looks.
posted over a year ago 
*
and I personally think that Harry is hotter than Edward. So it looks like Eddykins has nothing ;) lol
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
lmt96: Stop talking before you embarrass yourself. Wait, sorry, WAY too late.
MissKnowItAll posted over a year ago
*
lmt96: You do realize he's a fictional character, right?
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
ThatDamnLlama said:
... How come ignorant and narrow minded people waste their time asking senseless and naive questions?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
see the message in there, coolbek? And hate to brake it for ya, but Edward isn't real.
ThatDarnHippo posted over a year ago
*
Well Harry isn't real either, but I see what your saying
boolander25 posted over a year ago
*
lol i like how you bolded "Ignorant" "Narrow minded" "Senseless" and "Naive"
hpfreak14 posted over a year ago
VampiresRevenge said:
1. Harry actually has a personality.
2. Harry doesn't sparkle.
3. Harry has a brain.
4. Harry has a girlfriend with a brain.
5. Harry is gorgeous on the inside (and out, in my opinion).

(You want me to continue..?)

(*My hate for Edward has no bounds.)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
=) Enough said...
sapphire007 posted over a year ago
*
TeamSiriusBlack: Hahaha! I can't help that I'm almost as awesome as Zack! :)
VampiresRevenge posted over a year ago
*
^ :P And as narcisistic as Booth XD! Jk, but I call being Sweets!
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
PrinceMJluv said:
Because Harry Potter isn't abusive, he's cute, he's the boy who lived, he isn't "sparkly" and when he was dating Ginny you didn't see him doing anything wrong to her did you? Plus, Harry has a much better personality and cares for other people. He actually WORRIES about his friends getting hurt because of him! Edward Cullen isn't "gorgeous" heck, he's not even SPARKLY! He's crazy!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
exactly.
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
You said it! :)
Aquamarina posted over a year ago
*
How is he not abusive?
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
MadamOcta13 said:
Oh, let me count the ways...

At any point, did Harry stalk the girls he liked?
Does he take up quoting Shakespeare as a hobby (and if he did, he'd probably do it better)?
Does he choose his girlfriends by sniffing them?
Does he sparkle?

The answer to all of these questions is "NO!"

Now...

Does Edward have personality?
Does Edward have flaws?
Can anyone have a decent, normal conversation with him?
Does he sacrifice himself to save THE ENTIRE HUMAN RACE?
Does Edward have an opinion on anything other than Bella?
Are Edward's struggles relateable?
Do you ever feel bad for Edward?
Does Edward ever loose anyone close to him (death)?

The answer to all of these questions is "NO!"

I hope that answered your question.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
To add to your list of Edtard things, 'WOULD he risk his life for the entire human race?'
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
*
Nice. :)
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
*
"Sniffing Them" XD I am sorry but that sounded really wrong and perverted
hpfreak14 posted over a year ago
sleazy_weasley said:
'Because not everyone is a shallow reader' - thank you, you said it all.
Because we don't like our characters based on their looks, we like them based on their personalities.
Because sacrificing yourself for the entire human race owns sacrificing yourself only for your loved one to notice you any day.
Because we appreciate good literature.

I worry for future generations. And I can tell you haven't read any of the Harry Potter books, so stop ranting on about how hot Eddykins is compared to Harry. Try arguing about the plot lines, character developments, and/or messages portrayed in the books. (Oh that's right, Twilight doesn't have any!) - Unless you count all the 'Right. My boyf's left me, so ima go fall in love with another guy til Eddie comes back' or 'it's okay to stalk someone as long as you 'love' them' or 'it's okay to ditch your friends for your boyfriend and his rich siblings.'
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Don't forget: "if my boyfriend ever dumps me/moves/dies, it's okay to commit suicide to hear his voice" and "it's okay to have a boyfriend who wants to hurt me as long as he says that he loves me".
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
*
Haha true, very true. :)
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
potterandtdi said:
look in my dictionary:

ed-ward cull-en: sparkly vampire(aka fairy)

har-ry pott-er: awesome kid
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I like your kind of dictionary XD Whoa perverted thoughts DX
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
O.o
potterandtdi posted over a year ago
*
"Aka fairy" XDXDXD, just the best.
Neytiri1045 posted over a year ago
bangelfan said:
Um, he's hotter..and he doesn't "sparkle"
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Spuffy! <3
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
*
Spike and Angel are one of the hottest :)
bangelfan posted over a year ago
sapherequeen said:
Because we all have different tastes in books.....and it shouldn't offend anyone else (not accusing people).
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i definately agree, they're 2 diff types of books- action and romance ...well i havent actually read twillight yet, but i am looking forward to trying the series
tomboy980980 posted over a year ago
*
@tomboy: Interesting thought; you say action and romance? Which is which? I'd say it's more like love and lustful fairytale ... (HP and Twilight).
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
Neytiri1045 said:
Well, because he is Harry Potter! Not a sparkly-idiot-not-gorgeous-at-all-vampire.
Harry Potter is awsome ^^
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
aggred
ginny_potter_97 posted over a year ago
Ash24 said:
i guess hp can relate more to us and edward is only this unrelatable character but its only my opinion not criticisng those who love edward
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That´s so true. How shall any reader relate to a person who´s perfect?
Aquamarina posted over a year ago
*
o yes cause the dorky wizard is way more relatable then the vampire that goes to high school
lmt96 posted over a year ago
*
How is choosing between necrophilia and bestiality part of everyday life?
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
ChocAttack266 said:
You can find my response to this question in a separate article - it was too long to post as an answer.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
whats the article called?
MissKnowItAll posted over a year ago
*
Just "Response to 'how come people like hp better than gorgeous edward cullen'". Sorry it took me a while to get back to you, by the way...you've probably found it already by now.
ChocAttack266 posted over a year ago
AprilCandy42 said:
Eh? Are you kidding me? Harry looks better than Edtard. He doesn't ditch his friends a lot (even if he and Ron had a fight, they didn't leave each other's side), and you know this thing called "gender"? Harry isn't gay but Edwart is (I mean SPARKLING?! *Hermione voice* What. An. Idiot).
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Nice last line too!
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
*
Edtard! Love it!
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
*
lol
Ash24 posted over a year ago
*
im a hp fan, but...... u cant really say that one is better than the other because one is better looking--- first of all, everyone has diff ideas of who is gud looking. secondly, THEYRE BOTH IMAGINARY MADE UP CHARACTERS IN A BOOK -no one has any idea what they actually ;look like (besides maybe the authour) -its the actors in the movies that u r saying are gud looking
tomboy980980 posted over a year ago
PygmyPuff14 said:
1. Harry doesn't sparkle. Please note that sparkling makes Edward Cullen weird(Edit: It also makes him gay), not gorgeous.
2. Sane people tend to find stalkers (read: Edward Cullen) creepy.
3. Harry does not say lame things like, "the lion fell in love with the lamb"
4. Harry does not abuse Ginny.
5. Harry goes to HOGWARTS, not Forks High School.
6. Harry destroys the most evil wizard of all time while Edward Cullen is busy sparkling.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I disagree with 1; it makes Edward GAY.
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
*
Gay AND Weird.
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
*
So, you're saying, lmt96, if your boyfriend put some sparkly make up on and painted himself chalk white, you'd think he was still straight? And attractive? Gosh some people can be so shallow...
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
helenacrazy said:
look now harry potter is a series of great books and awsome flims edward is just one vampire of course people like hp more because flims and books or one person think about it dude!.sparkling??? wtf its really abnormal .anyway harry survived a freakin killing curse he actually EATS food unlike edward he defeats the dark lord while edward is busy stalking and smelling and harry is alive you can barely call edward alive ....
select as best answer
look now harry potter is a series of great books and awsome flims edward is just one vampire of course people like hp more because flims and books or one person think about it dude!.sparkling??? wtf its really abnormal .anyway harry survived a freakin killing curse he actually EATS food unlike edward he defeats the dark lord while edward is busy stalking and smelling and harry is alive you can barely call edward alive ....
posted over a year ago 
*
LOL, gotta love the TRUE Bella X)
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
lol yeah BellaTRIX vs. Bella. I think we all know who'd win.
emlincr posted over a year ago
ilovereading said:
1. edward cullen is NOT gorgeous (he is dead and sparkly)
2. some people like others having personality
3. hp is not crazy stalker with tendency to eat people

select as best answer
1. edward cullen is NOT gorgeous (he is dead and sparkly)
2. some people like others having personality
3. hp is not crazy stalker with tendency to eat people
posted over a year ago 
*
love the picture
jedigal1990 posted over a year ago
*
awwh the kitty sed it all!
1-2vampire posted over a year ago
*
I love kitties!
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
ABDCFan- said:
Nobody cares about Edtard, the only thing they like about him is his looks. You have quite clearly demonstrated this within your question. Well done.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MissKnowItAll said:
Because Harry is a nicer person. He's not a stalker. Not everyone is as shallow as you.


Also, Harry is better looking that Eddiekins.

Edward is an easter egg. You look at him and think you want him, but that's it. There is no chocolate inside an easter egg. Nothing at all.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
0_0 There's no chocolate? :( sadness
boolander25 posted over a year ago
*
Then what about the dementors? There's no choclate! How will we relieve if wer passed out?! Edward makes a useless easter egg.
AprilCandy42 posted over a year ago
*
Edward's head is shaped like a potato....
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
tymple said:
what gorgess edward cullen? no seriesly you might want to go see a doctor,siciatrist maybee an eye doctor.its ok im here for you well get through this.
select as best answer
what gorgess edward cullen? no seriesly you might want to go see a doctor,siciatrist maybee an eye doctor.its ok im here for you well get through this.
posted over a year ago 
*
*giggles* True image of what some crazy Twitards are doing to themselves. :)
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
*
They are SO doing it wrong.
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
*
^^ LOL coz the finger's pointing on the boyfriend of the girl and the picture and loving Edward instead of her boyfriend is wrong :D
ryomaidol posted over a year ago
Zina17 said:
How come people read Sappy twilight instead of exciting Harry Potter?

Dont get me wrong, i like them both, but even if you dont like one of them, you dont go around dissing it, esspecially on a spot made for fans of both >:(

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
^Exactly
LifesGoodx3 posted over a year ago
*
especially if u havent actually read the other one :P
tomboy980980 posted over a year ago
vskparaimer said:
It's because people who like HP more that gorgeous Edward Cullen don't care if he's "gorgeous" or not, but they care about his personality. People who like HP don't really say he's hot and that's why they love him.
So, coolbek, if you like the gorgeous Edward Cullen becoz he's gorgeous, i advise you to think once more.

And don't offend me, HP fans, i prefer Draco and Snape over Harry ;)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I'm totally there with you, vsk. (Can't be bothered typing out your whole username). LOL, that was a waste of space. Anyway, I could scarcely agree with you more! I LOVE Draco and Snape. They own Harry, haha. :D
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
next question »