answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

Harry Potter vs. Twilight

>>To all Harry Potter haters:
>>Question:

What is the MAIN reason why do you don't like Harry Potter?

(Give 1 reason and explain.)

>>To all Twilight haters:
>>Question:

What is the MAIN reason why do you don't like Twilight?

(Give 1 reason and explain.)


:)


 mitchie19 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight  best answer

ThatDamnLlama said:
Why I hate Twilight:

1. The plot. Mostly because there is no plot.

2. Bella Swan. She's shallow, selfish, a Mary-Sue, and stupid. She lusts (Not love. Lust.) Edward because he's hot and he smells good. She abandons her friends. She's 'perfect'. Perfect = dull = boring.

3. Edward Cullen. He is a 100-year-old sparkling virgin who watches a 17-year-old girl sleep. Need I say more?

4. Renesmee. DEMON CHILD! DEMON CHILD! ("Hairspray" reference)

5. Stephenie Meyer. She writes a whole series based off of a wet dream. She ruined vampire and werewolf mythology, and she can't write for her life. She gives women a bad name.

6. The characters. The whole story revolves and Edward and Bella. Bella and Edward. SMeyer leaves out the minor characters. None of the characters develop and change, like how characters should.

7. SMeyer is a weak writer. She's afraid to kill off characters, because 'they are perfect and deserve to live'. JKR wasn't afraid to kill her characters, even the ones we've come to know and love. And guess what? It didn't ruin the story, it made it better - relatable and understanding. People - friends, family - die in the real world. It's a fact of life.

8. The happy ending. There are no such things as happy endings. How old are we? 5? People old enough to read Twilight should understand that life is hard, and a book with a perfect and happy ending won't teach any lessons on how to get us through the worst of times.

9. Where are the themes? 'It is important to have a boyfriend to solve all your worthless problems' is a bad theme. Harry Potter has life lessons on confronting fears, facing hardship, sticking close to the ones you love, and much more.

10. The movies. I gotta hand it to ya guys, the movies, especially the first, were very enjoyable. The Twilight movie made my evening. It was such a good laugh. For most horrible films, you never want to see them again. But for Twilight, you think, "Is this real? Did they actually make a movie this bad? Is it a spoof?" Yeah. The movie was hilarious, and I will keep on watching it again and again.

11. The fans. I'm not going into this. We all know what the fans are like. *sigh*

12. The stupidity of it all. Sparkling vampires, fangirls gone mad, horrible books making a best seller, you get the picture.

Sorry I couldn't only give one reason why I hate it. That's impossible when it comes to something as laughable and horrible as *cough weeze cough* Tw- Tw*l*ght.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Epic Win!!!
AprilCandy42 posted over a year ago
*
*high fives* :D
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
*
*votes best answer*
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

abitofaLunaTic said:
Twilight: The lack of even one strong female character.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ToyletGnome said:
Serious lack of development in terms of characters and plot.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That's really the main one, but there's a huge amount more.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
LoopyLuna96 said:
Twilight: Weak females.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Agreed.
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
ABDCFan- said:
Twilight: You can't use the main female character as a role model, because of her mary-sueness.
Also, it's a very laughable and pathetic book with no plot. *sighs*

The only things I like about this whole Twilight saga thing are the soundtracks. Only because they've introduced me to new bands, and they have good music on them (well some of the songs are good).
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
like Muse? i've always known Muse way before Twilight. it's annoying seeing all this Twitards saying they love Muse because of Twilight. The band, Muse, doesn't even like Twilight. they hate it, even though it got them more famous.
ThatDamnLlama posted over a year ago
*
Oh, i knew Muse waaaaay before Twilight! I meant bands that aren't famous, or weren't famous, like Iron&Wine, and Band Of Skulls, etc etc. I wouldn't be surprised if Muse hated Twilight, alot of people do. Hurrah for Antis!
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
*
Really? Before this comment i hated Muse because I thought they liked Toilet. Well, i might just have to listen to them now.
LoveforSeverus posted over a year ago
*
Ahahahaha, they're good. Some of their songs are a bit suckish though...
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
TeamSiriusBlack said:
Twilight: The Villians. They aren't evil enough for me. Villians are suppose to be the ultimate evil. They kill and everything. The volturi are just lazy. I also read a literature magazine that my teacher had with villians in it. Voldemort was in it. Apparently, his Pet Peeve (I thought of Peeves) is people calling him Tommy XD.
Also, there isn't any blood and guts. I'm more of a Edgar-Allan-Poe-Written-Style fan and J.K. Rowling supplies my need for that writing nicely.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
The whole series revolves around three villians (Victoria, Laurent, and James) and then the Volturi just come in.
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
And besides, The Volturi are supposidly the good people.
LoveforSeverus posted over a year ago
top-star said:
i don't hate hp but i do hate its fans who keep on critcizing twilight and abusing it on no strong basis or inauthentic information and the proof can be seen in the above answers
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
How long have you been on the spot? There are actually many articles, comments, answers, etc. that give very detailed arguments with evidence from the books. The reason people aren't going into detail here is just that it said one reason, and we've done all the explaining a million times before. Look around the spot, and I guarrantee there are real arguments. You just have to look.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
Starfire127 said:
I don't hate harry Potter i seen one movie of harry potter and that it i kinda don't understand the whole dark magic and where is god in the movie?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
um...God? why would he be in Harry Potter...? Unless you made a typo and meant good...If you meant good, then you really have to read the books. But if you're looking for God, you won't find him there.
wotcher-tonks posted over a year ago
wotcher-tonks said:
Couldn't of said it better than ThatDamnLlama(:
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »