Why is a Critical Analysis of Twilight spot allowed, but a Critical Analysis of Justin Bieber isn't?

Because Twilight is a book series, so you can analyse things like plot and themes, Justin Bieber is a person, there isn't really anything about him to analyze. Critical analysis isn't code for place to insult, there are Twilight fans on the CAT spot too and even the antis have to try to express points fairly not just bash to follow the spot rules, so making a critical analysis of Justin Bieber spot wouldn't work as an outlet for insults.

On the CAT spot we are critiquing the books, not Stephenie Meyer or the fans as human beings. Since there is nothing to intellectually analyze about Justin Bieber there is nothing that could happen on that spot but people expressing dislike for him personally, which is rightfully not allowed on fanpop.

The closest thing I think you could fairly get away with is critical analysis of Justin Bieber's music (because then you would have lyrics and themes, so something to analyse) but unless you have a genuine interest in exploring the themes and effect of his music there isn't much point even in that, since I can't imagine it having any effect on those who just wish to insult rather than debate.
For people who just want to insult all you can do is report them and don't reward their trolling with a reaction.

Well, according to your views, I am immature and hate people for no reason. Two stereotypes I suffer from already, so it doesn't matter to me :)

I don't necessarily think that it's ridiculous, but I do think it's unnecessary.

You see, the CAT spot isn't just for people who dislike Twilight to voice their opinions on the series. It's there for Twilight haters to discuss the flaws and 'bad' messages they see within Twilight. They wish to evaluate Edward's 'abusive' behavior, Bella's 'submissive' personality, how the novels portray the roles of women (which to them are negative portrayals), and of course what the true myths of vampires are. The Critical Analysis of Twilight spot was made for all of these reasons.

Justin Bieber, as far as the majority knows, doesn't have any flaws like that. He isn't abusive, he isn't submissive, none of that applies to him.

He is simply a sixteen-year-old boy who is going through a stage in which he's very attracted to girls xD
And he has happened to have accomplished his dream as a well-known singer, which I have no problem with and actually admire :)

There's nothing to analyze about him, especially when magazines and the media is doing that for us already.

Also, the people who dislike Justin Bieber often express their opinions in the Random fanclub anyways, despite anyone's complaints.

because Justin Bieber's voice all of this stupid ridiculous crap is starting a stupid war between people just because of how ONE person sings

Because C.A.T. is a BOOK series. Justin Bieber is a LIVING PERSON. I don't think it's very appropriate to have a "critical analysis" of somebody, unless they did something big or unexpected and wrong, and even THEN that's crossing the line. I'm not a "fan" of Justin Bieber, but I don't see anything wrong with him. What you're doing is... very wrong. Sorry. :(

There are more things people can talk about the twilight books more then a stupid teen singer.
making a duplicate hate spot would only get the fans offended or insulted by the comments others would make about him.
i also hate him myself and his music because it's ruining the industry.
this is why questions like this shouldnt be posted otherwise people like you wouldnt get called names for mentioning justin queebers name.

well hah i hadnt thought about that:) i think its bc the penguins and twilight are just not humans and there is no chance they could have a fanpop ya mean?? i like this question...and why wud u wanna swaste ur time on somebodii u dont erven like???

I think it's more of the fact that with Twilight, there are books and therefore things to analyze about it. You can't really analyze a person (unless you're a psychologist and we're not that), so really to have a Critical Analysis of JB Spot would just be pointless. It would mainly just be haters on the spot talking about how they hate JB's signing or whatever. I don't really think anyone would take the actual time to really tolerate him, so a spot like that would just take up space.

I made a spot and the next time I logged in it had gone aswell!? Don't know why, Don't know how!

But I think we need a C.A.J.B. spot! I hate him!