Why?????????????

I don't really like We Are the Fallen. I respect those who do because it's their opinion, but I really find their music boring. Evanescence has always been a more creative type of band, and it's like WATF is trying and failing to be just as creative. Not to mention, while I find Evanescence's lyrics beautiful and meaningful, I always thought WATF were trying way too hard to have their lyrics match Evanescence's style but in the end they end up sounding very cheesy. Also, IMO Evanescence's music is overall darker, which I love, while WATF's album sounds more like Fallen's era (I consider Fallen more light-hearted than Origin and The Open Door). And seeing as I prefer the Origin and Open Door eras compared to Fallen in the first place, I don't think We Are the Fallen are ever going to win me over. Again, this is just my opinion.

I personally don't like WATF. But I never put down anyone that liked them or listened to them both. I have my own personal reason why I don't like WATF. That are legitimate claims on the lack of integrity of the band that I find faulty. But, listen to whatever you want to. I could care less lol.

ppl think Ben didnt do right with leaving Ev and creating another band with another old members of Ev...or some ppl think they are trying to do the same as Evanescence.i also like We are the fallen.some of their songs are really good!
i dont think Amy and Carly are A BIT similar!!!
i always ask myself how Ben could perform my immortal & going under again after leaving Evanescence...

I personally dislike WATF because some of their claims. Like for example in an interview Carly said "she never really listened to Evanescence" when on th American Idol tour she sang Bring Me to Life. They also try not to have association with Evanescence, but that's kind of tough considering they do covers from Fallen. I know Ben is totally entitled to because he helped write it. But still, he left Evanescence and continues to use the old stuff, and did you notice Bury Me Alive has a VERY similar intro to Bleed? I do respect your opinion though :)

I hate we are the fallen I don't care If people like theme or not
I hate theme cause they don't care about thier fans
actuly I feel they looking just for the money I didn't hear all thier music cause I don't have it I only listen to theme from the internet and not too much but I heard enough to make me see how bad they are
evanescence is perfect they have the most talnted singer in the world to be honest amy lee is better than ben moody as asongs writer
and evanescence do thier music they don't try to make thier music sounds like any other band when listen to theme you know this is evanescence

Totally agree!
People are too stubborn these days.
Move on and enjoy the music.
Both bands and all members are happy now. That's what matters.