I don't HATE Rose and I'm not mad she was voted best companion, but I honestly think she's the most overrated out of all of 'em. >.> I do like her, but compared to the others, she just seems like your generic, average, Mary Sue-ish spunky blonde. I don't get what's so awesome about her. Okay, so the Doctor falls in love with her and...? What else makes her character so special?

amy's well better

I agree; Amy's way awesomer. (GINGERS FTW!)

Amy is kind of annoying in my eyes.

I'm sure there were other companions who were far better than Rose.

I'd have given it to Ace! Baseball bat Dalek pwnage = Win

Amy, Ace, Jack, Donna, and Romana are the best! :D Rose was ok, but she can't beat them.

I don't think Rose is the best she's just the most popular/prominent. There were better.

Dearheart, you took the words right out of my mouth.

Rose was the best fucking thing on the show <3

Besides the 10th doctor ofcourse :)

But I would have been happy with Donna or Amy :)

Anyone but Martha...

me and my family hate her

I don't hate Rose, and Piper is a good actress, but Rose is VERY overrated. I got annoyed very quickly with her jealousy over anyone in the picture who had ovaries, and how completely self-centered she almost always was, unless the plot said that she had to be completely different.

I hate Rose!!! Nothing special about it, for what it so offer.
I'm more of Martha and Donna enjoy.
It would be better to acknowledge Donna, because it is unique

Rose is the best, compared to all the other companions!