List your current top 10overall favorite Creepypasta stories.

Notice I said stories, not characters.


1. ~ Penpal

2. ~ Psychosis

3. ~ My Sister Took Things

4. ~ 1999

5. ~ Plot Holes

6. ~ I Told You to Smile

7. ~ The Art of Jacob Emory

8. ~ I'm at Your Bedroom Window

9. ~ The Russian Sleep Experiment

10. ~ The Rake


My guess is that most people here haven't read 1, 3, 5 - 8 and possibly 2.