it is just the best dub for me! i LOVE shippuden!

:3 Vic does an amazing job with Ed<33

i agree,but al's original voice actor,aaron left and a WOMAN is voicing him. but al is a boy................

I haven't watch any of the above yet... but I'm definitely not choosing brotherhood. Like NarutoCrypt said, Aaron left. And that's enough to pierce a hole through my heart. But I suppose Maxey does it alright.

@NarutoCrypt: Many Voice Actors/Actresses voice opposite gender characters. And in the Japanese version, both Ed and Al are voiced by women. (Romi Park & Rie Kugimiya)

edward isnt voiced by a WOMAN. he is voiced by vic mignogna! and hes a guy! do you mean in brotherhood???? cuz vic does the original......

oh....O.O nevermind-@ kandrakar-sorry! i didnt see u put in the japanese version! SORRY!

It's quite common for women to voice guys/boys. China from Hetalia is voiced by a woman~

I have to say Brotherhood had a great dub! Though it just wont be the same without Aaron as Al (darn puberty!)