any suggestions of what i should watch now?

Definitely watch Natsume Yuujinchou! I see that it is on your list of planning to watch. It is my #1 favorite anime. Everything is so beautifully done about this anime; the story plots, the music, the character's growth and depth, the pacing. LOVE this anime.

And based on your list of ones you have watched you might like:
-Psychic Detective Yakumo
-The Devil is a Part-timer
-Eden of the East
-Guilty Crown
-07 Ghost
-Otome Youkai Zakuro

[To change it up, I'm going to post the opening of The Devil is a Part-timer!. It just came out in 2013 and I thought it was hilarious, had great characters, and was creative]

Anohana,kodocha,squid girl and the melchony of haruhi suzimiya you should really whatch them I think Im missing a couple but I think these are some of the BEST I ever watched im still thinking.....

The ones on your to-watch list that you should totally check out soon are Black Butler, AnoHana, Noragami (It's really great!), Chuunibyou, and NGE.
Based on your other animes, however, here are some good ones:
Nyan Koi
Princess Tutu
Death Note
XXX Holic
Highschool of the Dead (If you can deal with the fanservice)
.Hack
Log Horizon
The World God Only Knows (The anime is okay, but I really recommend the manga a lot, especially since the third season is very rushed and misses a lot of crucial plot and some other things that are really interesting.)

and of course, the PMMM spinoffs! They are manga though.