Highschool of the Dead - Made me jump a few times.
Elfen Lied - Made me jump more than a few times. xD
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni
Another
Umineko no Naku Koro ni
If I can think of any others I'll add them on here later. :)
Elfen Lied is one very scary anime! some parts I really had to turn away that's how scary that anime can be..especially the dog part!T.T..also Higurashi and Highschool of The Dead are two scary anime as well.
I only know of Death Note and Elfen Lied. Then again, Death Note is more of a suspense, action thriller...rather than horror. It didn't really scare me at all, but it depends on the person.
Elfen Lied hasn't scared me yet, but there's A LOT of gore and it's quite suspenseful..
1. Akira
2. Aoi Bungaku
3. Berserk
4. Betterman
5. Blassreiter
6. Blood+
7. Blood the Last Vampire
8. Blue Gender
9. Boogiepop Phantom
10. Boukyaku No Senritsu
11. Chaos Head
12. Dance in the Vampire Bund
13. Deadman Wonderland
14. Descendants of Darkness
15. Divergence Eve
16. Elfen Lied
17. Ga Rei Zero
18. Gantz
19. Ghost Hound
20. Ghost Hunt
21. Ghost Stories
22. Hakaba Kitarou
23. Hellsing (that includes Ultimate and The Dawn)
24. Highschool of the dead (and OVA)
25. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (that includes Kai and Rei)
26. Jigoku Shoujo (Hellgirl) (that includes Futakomori and Mitsuganae)
27. Kaidan Restaurant
28. Karin
I havn't found any of them scary yet, but they are great animes and they are under the horror genre. And who know maybe other people do find them scary. But I do know more if you want to hear more titles. To hear more titles just message me.
Vampire Knight!It's my favourite anime and it has 2 season,the 3rd doesn't come yet.Actually it's not as scary as High school of the dead or Elfen Lied,but this anime is a story about vampires so when a vampire drinks someone's blood,it acts really scary and the music plays in these parts are really scary too.Also,you will love the 3 main characters of the anime because they are very cool
Another
Mononoke
When they cry
Elfen lied
High school of the dead
Ayakashi samurai ghost tales
Gantz
There are many more anyone who thinks Kamina is the manliest man send me a message