answer this question

Anime Question

** CONTEST! Biggest Mary-Sue/Marty-Stu in anime!**

For those who are in the dark on this, a Mary-Sue is any character who is, to be blunt, flawless or perfect. Their most outstanding traits include beauty, intellect, power, tragic/mysterious past, and they may or may not have a fanclub of the opposite gender. A Marty-Stu is the male version.

My example: Sasuke. He's handsome, stupidly popular among the girls, has a dark past, and is considered a genius ninja for his age. Therefore, he passes the Marty-Stu test.

Be sure to explain what makes them a Mary-Sue/Marty-Stu! Winner receives 5 props! Deadline TBA.


** CONTEST! Biggest Mary-Sue/Marty-Stu in anime!**
*
wait is it a bad thing?
lumforever posted over a year ago
*
yeah. i'm sorry, i should've mentioned that.
CakeBoxSisters posted over a year ago
*
A Sue or Stu being bad is extremely perceptive. Just because a character has no flaws doesn't mean they're uninteresting. To me the fact they have no flaws makes them more interesting just for the fact they are so unrealisticly perfect. They might be a dud because they never change but in some cases there would be no show if there wasn't that one Sue/Stu in it. I can't remember off the top of my head but I've seen one or two.
xxtaysuicunexx posted over a year ago
 CakeBoxSisters posted over a year ago
next question »

Anime Answers

PeacefulCritic said:
Outer Moka from rosario+vampire. Let's go over what makes a non marry-sue.

Does she have a real personality, you know with traits,flaws and boundaries? meh just traits, she is nice,thoughtful,smart,kind,honest,warm-hearted,selfless, elegant, hard-working, caring, playful, and pretty much any other strengths, you can think up in your head.

Is her design simple? Nah, actually it's pretty complex. She's often called the most gorgeous girl in school.Along with her brainless background characters gashing and falling for her, more the the other girls.

Can she hold her own sometimes but, still needs help sometimes? Nope, she needs constant help from everyone else, including Inner Moka, who's constantly saving people but, Outer Moka gets more love and most of the credit. since almost everyone thinks they are one in the same.

Yep, totally a marry-sue! sure there are other trails but, I'm pretty sure what the result is going to be so....
select as best answer
Outer Moka from rosario+vampire. Let's go over what makes a non marry-sue.

Does she have a real personality, you know with traits,flaws and boundaries? meh just traits, she is nice,thoughtful,smart,kind,honest,warm-hearted,selfless, elegant, hard-working, caring, playful, and pretty much any other strengths, you can think up in your head.

Is her design simple? Nah, actually it's pretty complex. She's often called the most gorgeous girl in school.Along with her brainless background characters gashing and falling for her, more the the other girls.

Can she hold her own sometimes but, still needs help sometimes? Nope, she needs constant help from everyone else, including Inner Moka, who's constantly saving people but, Outer Moka gets more love and most of the credit. since almost everyone thinks they are one in the same.

Yep, totally a marry-sue! sure there are other trails but, I'm pretty sure what the result is going to be so....
posted over a year ago 
angelbell619 said:
Maybe hatsune miku i dont know im confuse
select as best answer
Maybe hatsune miku i dont know im confuse
posted over a year ago 
*
I don't really think Miku counts since the creators didn't actually give her an actual personality. It's actually up to the fans to decide.
ChocoLuvr101 posted over a year ago
*
love her so i decide she counts!
narlyvamp1234 posted over a year ago
*
it depends on which song, Because most of the time volcaids can take on different roles in certain types of song even through she usually plays a character that adventurous,naive type.but, she can also sometimes play as the villain of the story in certain songs.My point is that,unless they made a real tv-show about vocoids you really can't say who the real Miku is.
PeacefulCritic posted over a year ago
Xustinua said:
Asuna Yuuki from Sword Art Online. She is not that great of a character at all. She is the strongest character in the game yet she does crap and gets weaker. And I don't like that she married Kirito. It should have been Lizbeth and him.
She gets kidnapped by some guy and she doesn't save herself. She expects kirito too. She constantly gets all of the attention. She hit kirito for no reason in one episode. I hope they get rid of her later in the show. She is a bad character and the worse type of Modern Sues you can find
select as best answer
Asuna Yuuki from Sword Art Online. She is not that great of a character at all. She is the strongest character in the game yet she does crap and gets weaker. And I don't like that she married Kirito. It should have been Lizbeth and him. 
She gets kidnapped by some guy and she doesn't save herself. She expects kirito too. She constantly gets all of the attention. She hit kirito for no reason in one episode. I hope they get rid of her later in the show. She is a bad character and the worse type of Modern Sues you can find
posted over a year ago 
*
Kirito is worse get rid of him and make asuna the hero
amyrosethefirst posted over a year ago
amyrosethefirst said:
Takumi Usui from Maid Sama. He's handsome, athletic, can cook, plays the violin, unbeatable at chess and beach volleyball and has harems of women and men chasing him....
Too bad Misaki doesn't care. To her he's just a "twisted alien."

Kirito from sword art online is this in the games he plays....in real life...well there's a reason he loves games
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bruhhhhhhhh69 said:
Violet Evergarden!
I mean, she's a former military soldier who can kill about anybody in a moments notice, she has a tragic backstory, she's rather great at her job , and she's extremely beautiful.
select as best answer
Violet Evergarden!
I mean, she's a former military soldier who can kill about anybody in a moments notice, she has a tragic backstory, she's rather great at her job , and she's extremely beautiful.
posted over a year ago 
*
Two things really nail her as a Mary Sue: Adulatory monologues from side characters at the end of the episode, "ahh i can't believe I met violet she chaaaanged my life writing a letter!" and that her weakness in not understanding emotions is actually a good thing for other characters. She cannot do wrong even if she tries and that makes her a textbook Mary Sue.
shalissar posted over a year ago
lumforever said:
well how bout invader lum? she beautiful of course! she even has her own body guards and gets all the boys attention. she has power. she can shoot lightning at ataru. she pretty smart. i wouldnt say she has a tragic past. and she can rock a tiger skin bikini. but in this pic shes not wearing it. she also has her little cousin ten follow her around everywhere! like my user name says it all: lum forever!
select as best answer
well how bout invader lum? she beautiful of course! she even has her own body guards and gets all the boys attention. she has power. she can shoot lightning at ataru. she pretty smart. i wouldnt say she has a tragic past.  and she can rock a tiger skin bikini. but in this pic shes not wearing it. she also has her little cousin ten follow her around everywhere! like my user name says it all: lum forever!
posted over a year ago 
*
A Mary-Sue is a bad thing..
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
*
how
lumforever posted over a year ago
*
thanks for explainig! oops. i guess i was wrong.
lumforever posted over a year ago
SneakyFox48 said:
So I would stay that my Marty-Stu would be the Pharaoh Atem. So he's handsome, he's got control/king of the shadow realm, he's smart enough to out wit his enemies, definitely has a tragic past with the whole spirit in a 5,000 year old item, and of course he has a fan club... I mean his is somewhat a celebrity. (even if he is using Yugi's body)
That's also my reasoning as to why I love Yugi tons more... there is nothing better than a flawed character!
select as best answer
So I would stay that my Marty-Stu would be the Pharaoh Atem. So he's handsome, he's got control/king of the shadow realm, he's smart enough to out wit his enemies, definitely has a tragic past with the whole spirit in a 5,000 year old item, and of course he has a fan club... I mean his is somewhat a celebrity. (even if he is using Yugi's body)
That's also my reasoning as to why I love Yugi tons more... there is nothing better than a flawed character!
posted over a year ago 
inuyasha15 said:
kikyo!!!!!!
select as best answer
kikyo!!!!!!
posted over a year ago 
*
Actually, Kikyou has many faults in her personality
NV99 posted over a year ago
twilightrox43 said:
I'm going with Saya Takagi.

Saya is pretty (in its sense), considered a genius, has a famous and rich family, and is very clever and able to hold her own in itself.
Personally, I think she's a Mary Sue, but her somewhat stubborn and arrogant personality could tell people otherwise.
select as best answer
I'm going with Saya Takagi.

Saya is pretty (in its sense), considered a genius, has a famous and rich family, and is very clever and able to hold her own in itself. 
Personally, I think she's a Mary Sue, but her somewhat stubborn and arrogant personality could tell people otherwise.
posted over a year ago 
Animeshnica said:
sasuke~kun! ^^
select as best answer
sasuke~kun! ^^
posted over a year ago 
coolcat1868 said:
Ichigo mommiya!
From tokyo mew mew!
Shes so cute and funny!
She has a wonderful personaity and shes really loyal!
select as best answer
Ichigo mommiya!
From tokyo mew mew!
Shes so cute and funny!
She has a wonderful personaity and shes really loyal!
posted over a year ago 
*
I completely agree :P
niamhxxx posted over a year ago
*
thanks!Shes a classic character!
coolcat1868 posted over a year ago
*
Then shes not a Mary Sue. A Mary Sue has no flaws, a boring personality, and sucks all around.
SymmaGirl2 posted over a year ago
*
not a mary sue she's just a sweetie. she is also a wackyass so she does have flaws. (lol she was late for her first date)
amyrosethefirst posted over a year ago
pumpkinqueen said:
I hate it when people call characters that, it's an overrated thing to call anybody. But if that's what Mary-Sue means. Then all the best characters in shows are like that! So what if a character is perfect, beautiful, or has a tragic story. That is what makes them a wonderful character. It's better then being a boring jerk character with no personality.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I strongly disagree, but I respect your opinion. Ty for posting.
CakeBoxSisters posted over a year ago
*
mary sues have no character
luv_warriorcatz posted over a year ago
Tsubasathira said:
Syaoran from tsubasa
select as best answer
Syaoran from tsubasa
posted over a year ago 
lumina_louella said:
Kenshin Himura for me. He has the looks, intellect, unbelievable talent in handling a sword and a tragic/mysterious past. It fits him perfectly. ;]

select as best answer
Kenshin Himura for me. He has the looks, intellect, unbelievable talent in handling a sword and a tragic/mysterious past. It fits him perfectly. ;]
posted over a year ago 
lawliet5097 said:
Itachi Uchiha
Smart, intellegent, cool, guenuis, strong, and a prodigy
select as best answer
Itachi Uchiha
Smart, intellegent, cool, guenuis, strong, and a prodigy
posted over a year ago 
narlyvamp1234 said:
Cossette D'Avenue, look her up and read her past, it is very tragic. she is from the Anime series "Le portrait de petit Cossette."
select as best answer
Cossette D'Avenue, look her up and read her past, it is very tragic. she is from the Anime series "Le portrait de petit Cossette."
posted over a year ago 
*
I love cossette~
esmeralda15 posted over a year ago
Bananaaddict said:
Tohru Honda...but I still like her.
select as best answer
Tohru Honda...but I still like her.
posted over a year ago 
*
I love Tohru, she's so sweet. She's my second favorite anime girl. :)
pumpkinqueen posted over a year ago
*
she's so sweet
NV99 posted over a year ago
*
Um, I kinda of disagree she is clumsy,socially awkward, stubborn, determine, and overly protective but, I guess that's just an opinion so, it doesn't matter that much.
PeacefulCritic posted over a year ago
KatrinaCrane said:
Edward Elric is pretty much a Gary-stu XD
He's still my fave anime character though :)
Tragic past? Check.
Tragic family death? Check.
Dis-figuration that makes him more attractive(the automail)? Check.
Chick magnet? LOL no -.-; he's a midget jerk.
Ends up with a beautiful love interest? Check.

Not to mention he is the YOUNGEST STATE ALCHEMIST, and he ended up being the biggest Hero in Promised Day, without his contribution all of the people in his country would have died.
and I mean look at him, HE'S PRETTAY~ only he's short...and a pretty big jerk/dunce.
Meh still a Mary-Sue.

Oh yeah forgot to mention, this is manga/brotherhood based XD in the original anime it's almost the same except he doesn't end up with a "beautiful love interest" :/
select as best answer
Edward Elric is pretty much a Gary-stu XD
He's still my fave anime character though :)
Tragic past? Check.
Tragic family death? Check.
Dis-figuration that makes him more attractive(the automail)? Check.
Chick magnet? LOL no -.-; he's a midget jerk.
Ends up with a beautiful love interest? Check.

Not to mention he is the YOUNGEST STATE ALCHEMIST, and he ended up being the biggest Hero in Promised Day, without his contribution all of the people in his country would have died.
and I mean look at him, HE'S PRETTAY~ only he's short...and a pretty big jerk/dunce.
Meh still a Mary-Sue.

Oh yeah forgot to mention, this is manga/brotherhood based XD in the original anime it's almost the same except he doesn't end up with a "beautiful love interest" :/
posted over a year ago 
SymmaGirl2 said:
Masaya Aoyama from Tokyo Mew Mew.
He's stunningly handsome, captain of the kendo club, righteous, is devoted to his true love, can transform into a knight that was born from his wish to protect the main character, loves the environment, is the heartthrob of the entire school, and turns out to be the main bad guy's extra persona for when he was gaining power. He has no bad qualities.
In other words, he sucks.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Esira said:
This one.....
I hate how she's supposed to be a perfect beauty, perfect fighter and perfect everything!
And she's STILL boring.
select as best answer
This one.....
I hate how she's supposed to be a perfect beauty, perfect fighter and perfect everything!
And she's STILL boring.
posted over a year ago 
*
no, Mikasa has a cold personality and damaged mentaliy, that's far from boring IMO
NV99 posted over a year ago
Itzcc6872 said:
Erza Scarlet. Yes, I still really like her, but she is kinda a Mary Sue.

Beautiful? Yes.
Bad Past? Yes.
Amazing Fighter? Yes.
Intimidating? Yes.
A power that not many people can master? YES.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah, but she has her quirks that are shown before an arc, i still love her
NV99 posted over a year ago
NV99 said:
i have 3 because they're so BORING. Chi from BroCon, she literally has the personality of a cereal box, just to sway guys affections and morals. Esther from Trinity Blood, she's is the reason everything went into "chaos" in the end. You guys know what's next, Kagome, paint drying is more interesting than her, everything would've been easier if someone said "Pick up an arrow and shoot", even when she's at fault people say " InuYasha apologize" no, she's being a brat
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
mamalu1g1 said:
Medaka Korokami
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Mono11037 said:
Chiaki Nanami in Danganronpa 3: Despair arc (SPOILERS)

She is a gamer girl who somehow manages to pretty much single-handedly make everyone get along. Everyone says she should be class rep without even considering anyone else. When she dies, the entire rest of her class turn to despair and DESTROY THE WORLD because they miss her or some other bull. She is shown as flawless, beautiful and perfect, and I hate every pretty little inch of her.
select as best answer
Chiaki Nanami in Danganronpa 3: Despair arc (SPOILERS)

She is a gamer girl who somehow manages to pretty much single-handedly make everyone get along. Everyone says she should be class rep without even considering anyone else. When she dies, the entire rest of her class turn to despair and DESTROY THE WORLD because they miss her or some other bull. She is shown as flawless, beautiful and perfect, and I hate every pretty little inch of her.
posted over a year ago 
Outfinity said:
Violet Evergarden
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »