He can be mean when adding in his not so nice unnecasary thoughts (ex. you sounded like a cat falling off of the empire state building). But he does know how to define talent and he completes the show.

simons the one who is usually right about a person's talent and how far the will make it. hes my fav idol judge

gosselin fan, I luved that comment! It was hilarious!
He makes the show. My fav judge obviously.
I <3 Simon!!