American Idol Smad!!!

Heptephobiac posted on Mar 20, 2008 at 12:47PM
I am so smad (sad & mad) that Amanda went home! She was my favorite! How did her and Carly end up in the bottom three?! Kristy should have went home! I'm so smad I don't even know what else to say!
last edited on Mar 23, 2008 at 12:25AM

American Idol 13 replies

Click here to write a response...
over a year ago Schmidty said…
I agree with you Heptephobiac 100% What thew heck was America thinking? Kristie should have gone home last night not Amanda...plus I don't understand why Carly or Amanda was in the bottom three anyways...hmmm Amanda is awsome, so I'm hoping that she gets a record deal sometime soon!
over a year ago Heptephobiac said…
word.
over a year ago ineedcoffee said…
I totally agree I just don't understand how america could vote Amanda out but keep Kristy, who has been consistantly in the bottom 3.
over a year ago harold said…
It's almost become a joke with Kristy. You could see how she nodded with a little grin this past week (week 5 of season 7) when Seacrest told her she was in the bottom three, sort of "Yeah, what else is new?"

Yesterday I had an horrible premonition: wouldn't it be terrible if, after all that, she ends up as the next Idol?
over a year ago ineedcoffee said…
bite your tounge you may just have jinxed the whole show...lol
over a year ago Heptephobiac said…
Ooh yeah, scary thought, let's not think about it.
over a year ago harold said…
Well, I expect further horrors tonight...
over a year ago Heptephobiac said…
As do I.
over a year ago ineedcoffee said…
dang it!!!! now micheal is gone I didn't even see that one coming.
over a year ago dave said…
Yeah that was RIDICULOUS. Michael was clearly one of the three best (next to Cook and Archuleta). America clearly has no taste.
over a year ago ineedcoffee said…
I agree dave no taste at all.
over a year ago harold said…
Unbelievable. He was the one who was improving the most, week-over-week. I guess that isn't a big criterion for the majority of voters, which shows that the pick results might be somewhat indicative of the larger body of US voters...
over a year ago Heptephobiac said…
Carly Smithson and I did the exact same thing when Ryan said her and Syesha were safe. It went a little something like this, "What?" Michael gone over Syesha, or even Kristy? Come on, really? I'm now going to join the rest of the world in speechlessness.