Akatsuki

answer this question

Akatsuki Question

Is My Tobi's Identity theory right?

Ok, My Tobi identity theory is like alot of people, in my opinion, Tobi is Obito. But I will actually give you something to consider, before you reject it.
Besides the fact that they have similar hair, and name, the facts about Obito that they have given us would easily apply Tobi. They said when obito died he gave Kakashi his left eye(Sharingan). Now tell me, which eye is covered by the mask on Tobi.
This created another big arguement when in the manga/anime, when tobi fought Konan, he revealed his other sharingan. Many thought that this meant that it couldn't be obito, because he had both eyes. However, if he had both, why did he need to block one? Then it hit me, he's just like Kakashi, it's not his sharingan. Uchiha's can completely control their eyes, and that of a siblings, anyone else's is different. This means the Obito theory could still be true!
But then people asked if that's true, how did he get another sharingan if they're all dead? The answer is, that itachi was telling the truth when he said he didn't kill off all of the Uchiha clan on his own. Madara Uchiha(Tobi)helped, and took most likely took an eye from someone powerful. He's already proven he can apply a sharingan to a person's eye socket(When he put itachi's eyes in sasuke).
So these are my reasons why I believe Tobi is Obito...
Who agrees and who disagree????
 T-William posted over a year ago
next question »

Akatsuki Answers

sleepwalkers said:
I believe it's Obito too because in the manga which is more important scince it is the original they have a discussion between Tobi and Kabuto and Kabuto has the dead (emphisis) on the dead body of Madara Uchiha but then again Kabuto can fake bodies but pay attention because Gobi is worried that he will show others the corpse now I may be thinking to deep into this but it makes sense right? And yes I believe the mask thing too! And it makes more sense cuz scince. Ninjas collect all bodies of nins no matter what they would have told if Obito was dead or not and they did NOT FIND ANY BODY! Do you agree?
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I've read the manga, and everything you've said makes perfect sense. I completely believe you
T-William posted over a year ago
RedPineapple said:
That is a good theory...but, there are still a few facts proving otherwise. Like the fact that Tobi's actual voice is way deeper and different than Obito's voice. I doubt such a drastic voice change could occur.. (Have you read the most recent Naruto Shippuden chapters? Or maybe watched the recent episodes? I don't want to spoil anything.. >_>')

In any case, the series revealed Tobi to be Madara Uchiha, the one who assisted Itachi in eliminating the Uchiha clan. This theory lasted for a long while and it seemed to make sense, until the most recent events in the anime/manga. ~**SPOILER ALERT**~




Okay, so... in the ninja war, 'Tobi' and Kabuto are resurrecting shinobi who have died and using them to fight off the ninja villages. During the war, we still think that Tobi is Madara until, Madara gets resurrected, signalling that he really did die. At that moment, no one knew who Tobi was any more. He is now referred to as either just Tobi...or The Masked Man... I am still uncertain about who Tobi really is, but I'm starting to think he's not Obito. (He may be an experiment? Part of Madara's DNA? An unknown Uchiha? Someone else's soul using Obito's body?) I don't know..
select as best answer
That is a good theory...but, there are still a few facts proving otherwise. Like the fact that Tobi's actual voice is way deeper and different than Obito's voice. I doubt such a drastic voice change could occur.. (Have you read the most recent Naruto Shippuden chapters? Or maybe watched the recent episodes? I don't want to spoil anything.. >_>') In any case, the series revealed Tobi to be Madara Uchiha, the one who assisted Itachi in eliminating the Uchiha clan. This theory lasted for a long while and it seemed to make sense, until the most recent events in the anime/manga. ~**SPOILER ALERT**~ Okay, so... in the ninja war, 'Tobi' and Kabuto are resurrecting shinobi who have died and using them to fight off the ninja villages. During the war, we still think that Tobi is Madara until, Madara gets resurrected, signalling that he really did die. At that moment, no one knew who Tobi was any more. He is now referred to as either just Tobi...or The Masked Man... I am still uncertain about who Tobi really is, but I'm starting to think he's not Obito. (He may be an experiment? Part of Madara's DNA? An unknown Uchiha? Someone else's soul using Obito's body?) I don't know..
posted over a year ago 
*
Some people think that Tobi is a Zetsu created my Madara but the Zetsu then sort of rebelled and took Madara DNA or chakra and became him after he killed him
DarkJules posted over a year ago
*
Great point! However, I never believed Tobi to be Madara because none of his ninjutsu matched the madara's. I still believe it's obito, because, (you said the voices are different) tobi has the ability to change his voice when necessary. In the manga, he said that he is no one. That sounds like someone who has given up an identity(obito) and form a new more powerful persona...idk THERE'S SO MANY POSSIBILITIES!!!
T-William posted over a year ago
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
I still think he's Madara for many reasons.
xXitachiXx posted over a year ago
pokemonyellow said:
More like Tobi is an unknown Uchiha who claims to be Madara and confuses people into thinking he's Obito.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lirik14 said:
Look, to all of you guys, I highly doubt it's Obito. The manga says clearly that his right half was crushed. And Tobi is shown to be old without his mask, and Obito is at most Kakashi's age.

Now here is my and my brother's theory. We put some unfinished ends together and that's what we came up with. Even though I know a lot of you will disagree, I think it very likely.

Look, Tobi seems to know everything about Madara, and a great many other Uchiha secrets, including the Rinnegan being the next step after the Eternal Mangekyou. Who else could know so much about Madara, considering that not very much is know about him but a family member? Who could carry Madara's same grudge but a brother? Yes, I think Tobi may be Izuna Uchiha, I think that's his brother's name. Yes, the manga did say that Madara took his eyes, but they never say he died. So just like Madara took Izuna's eyes, couldn't Izuna have done the same thing when Madara died? If I were Izuna, I would, and I would be mad as hell for my brother being killed.

It may not seems very likely to many of you, but it is to me. Leave replies on your thoughts.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Listen i do somewhat agree with you there is a chance it may not be Obito but I know info that strongly prooves it is Obito because in the manga it shows that both kakkashi and guy know Tobi. But theres a possibility it may be kagami uchiha.
hurtingninja posted over a year ago
*
Turns out I was right! Hey, you guys gave the best arguments on why couldn't have been him though
T-William posted over a year ago
Kloud said:
It's possible. But it would either imply that Tobi was either two people behind one mask, or Obito traveled through time. Obito had not been born yet when Tobi gave Nagato the rinnegan.
Though in the last few chapters it's been revealed that Tobi does use the same eye technique as kakashi, and he knows both Kakashi and Gai. It's possible that someone took Obito's other eye from the rubble.

P.S: It's been already revealed that Tobi has a room filled with hundreds of sharingan eyes.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!